- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
What are your best potato salad recipes?
Posted on 1/19/25 at 11:31 am
Posted on 1/19/25 at 11:31 am
I’m making a gumbo tomorrow and want a good potato salad to go with it. I personally prefer one heavy on mustard but am open to any recipes.
Posted on 1/19/25 at 11:41 am to Tiger328
First thing to do is boil your potatoes in water seasoned with seafood boil. Just how much is up to you, but I like my potatoes to come out just like they do when I make a crawfish boil and nicely seasoned.
I then peel the potatoes if not already peeled and smash them up a good bit since I don't like big chunks of potatoes in the potato salad. Small bits and mostly creamy is my goal.
Things I add:
Diced onion
Diced celery
Diced Green Onion
Some Relish
Some cut up dill pickle
Diced salad olives w/pimento
Diced up boiled egg
Yellow mustard
Mayo
I usually don't need to add any salt/pepper since the potatoes are cooked in seasoned water, but you check and make it fit your needs.
I've served hundreds of pounds of this made exactly as described and have never had a complaint.
I then peel the potatoes if not already peeled and smash them up a good bit since I don't like big chunks of potatoes in the potato salad. Small bits and mostly creamy is my goal.
Things I add:
Diced onion
Diced celery
Diced Green Onion
Some Relish
Some cut up dill pickle
Diced salad olives w/pimento
Diced up boiled egg
Yellow mustard
Mayo
I usually don't need to add any salt/pepper since the potatoes are cooked in seasoned water, but you check and make it fit your needs.
I've served hundreds of pounds of this made exactly as described and have never had a complaint.
This post was edited on 1/19/25 at 1:50 pm
Posted on 1/19/25 at 11:53 am to Tiger328
The simpler the better when pairing PS with gumbo, but you asked for my best so here it is.
Omit the shrimp if serving with gumbo.
Omit the shrimp if serving with gumbo.
quote:
I don't have convenient access to crawfish in my neck of the woods, so I make Shrimp potato salad. It's the dish I most often bring it to cook-outs and parties. I cook my ingredients separately but in the same pot and same liquid to cut down on dishes and cross-utilize the water. First I poach the shrimp, then I cook the eggs and finally I cook the potatoes and mix them with the dressing while they are still hot. Once the potato salad is room temp, I fold the shrimp back in and adjust the seasoning and heat level.
Ingredients for the shrimp
#1.5 shrimp
8qts water
4each bay leaves
1each Zatarain's crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil in a bag
2T Zatarain's concentrated liquid shrimp & crab boil
4T Zatarain's granulated crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil
Bring water to boil in 12qt stock pot. Add all ingredients except the shrimp. Return to a boil, stir in shrimp and turn off heat. Put a tight-fitting lid on the pot and allow shrimp to poach 15-20 minutes (this is when I peel the potatoes and assemble the rest of my ingredients). Remove shrimp with a spider and leave them at room temperature while you prepare the rest of the ingredients.
Ingredients for the eggs and potatoes
4 each eggs
#2 russet potatoes, peeled quartered or cut into large pieces
reserved shrimp cooking liquid
Return pot to a boil, remove eggs from refrigeration and add immediately to boiling water. Cook for 5 minutes. Turn off heat add a tight-fitting lid and allow eggs to poach for an additional 10 minutes. After 10 minutes, immediately remove eggs with a spider and shock eggs in an ice bath. Peel eggs, separate the yolks, dice the whites, and prepare the dressing while the potatoes cook.
Add potatoes to the reserved cooking liquid, heat to a boil, lower to a simmer and cook potatoes 10 minutes or until desired doneness. Once potatoes are done, strain and add to dressing.
Ingredients for the dressing*
4each egg yolks from boiled eggs
4 each diced egg whites
1c Mayonnaise
2/3c diced onion
1/4c mustard
1T salt
1t black pepper
1T sugar
1T white vinegar
1 small clove of garlic, minced
to taste: Zatarain's concentrated liquid shrimp & crab boil & Zatarain's granulated crawfish, shrimp, & crab boil (about 1-2 teaspoons of each).
Blend the egg yolks with the vinegar to make sure they are broken down well, then add them to the mayonnaise.Mix all ingredients and reserve until potatoes are ready.
Mix everything and refrigerte overnight for best results.
*all measurements are approximations. adjust to your preference
Posted on 1/19/25 at 12:11 pm to BigDropper
Potatoes,
Boiled eggs, smash in with potatoes to desired consistency.
Add mayo-mustard mixture to desired consistency.
Optional dill pickle relish into the mix as well.
Boiled eggs, smash in with potatoes to desired consistency.
Add mayo-mustard mixture to desired consistency.
Optional dill pickle relish into the mix as well.
Posted on 1/19/25 at 12:13 pm to Tiger328
I made some for Christmas for gumbo.
Boiled 3 pounds of potatoes with a hefty amount of salt.
Mixed together a bunch of Duke’s mayo and a couple big squeezes of French’s yellow mustard with some salt and pepper.
Cut up one of the whole little plastic containers of dill that feels like such a rip off since I couldn’t find a bunch of it.
Cut the potatoes into sixths and mixed in after they cooled a little.
Rough mashed some but left them pretty chunky.
Let sit overnight.
Honestly one of the better potato salads I’ve had.
Boiled 3 pounds of potatoes with a hefty amount of salt.
Mixed together a bunch of Duke’s mayo and a couple big squeezes of French’s yellow mustard with some salt and pepper.
Cut up one of the whole little plastic containers of dill that feels like such a rip off since I couldn’t find a bunch of it.
Cut the potatoes into sixths and mixed in after they cooled a little.
Rough mashed some but left them pretty chunky.
Let sit overnight.
Honestly one of the better potato salads I’ve had.
Posted on 1/19/25 at 12:43 pm to Tiger328
I don't really have a recipe but I use what some might think is an absurd amount of boiled eggs. About a dozen with a batch which would be about 8 decent sized potatoes.
I don't use all the whites. Maybe the whites from 4-5 eggs but all of the yolks.
Mash the eggs in a bowl. Add mayo and seasoning, I mainly use celery salt and black pepper. Maybe a tablespoon of apple cider vinegar or better yet the liquid from pickled jalapeno peppers. A teaspoon or two of yellow mustard.
Mix all that up into a dressing and fold into the boiled potato chunks.
It ends up being yellow from the egg yolks. People think it's from the mustard but I don't use much mustard anymore.
I don't use all the whites. Maybe the whites from 4-5 eggs but all of the yolks.
Mash the eggs in a bowl. Add mayo and seasoning, I mainly use celery salt and black pepper. Maybe a tablespoon of apple cider vinegar or better yet the liquid from pickled jalapeno peppers. A teaspoon or two of yellow mustard.
Mix all that up into a dressing and fold into the boiled potato chunks.
It ends up being yellow from the egg yolks. People think it's from the mustard but I don't use much mustard anymore.
Posted on 1/19/25 at 1:06 pm to Tiger328
All of the best potato salad I’ve ever had has been “simple.” People try to over think it and put too much stuff into it.
Posted on 1/19/25 at 2:06 pm to gaetti15
quote:
Optional dill pickle relish into the mix as well.
Is it though?
Posted on 1/19/25 at 3:42 pm to calcotron
No. It absolutely should not be in gumbo potato salad. Just like all this shite:
This is gumbo potato salad:

quote:
Diced onion
Diced celery
Diced Green Onion
Some Relish
Some cut up dill pickle
Diced salad olives w/pimento
This is gumbo potato salad:

Posted on 1/19/25 at 4:44 pm to Tiger328
My mom has been making this since I was a kid and it’s great. My wife makes it now and is about to make some in a minute.
Fipp’s Family Potato Salad
Fipp’s Family Potato Salad
quote:
Ingredients:
4 pounds baking potatoes (8 large)
3 hard-cooked eggs, grated
1 cup mayonnaise
1 tablespoon spicy brown mustard
1 1/2 teaspoons salt
3/4 teaspoon pepper
quote:
Cook potatoes in boiling water to cover 40 minutes or until tender; drain and cool. Peel Potatoes, and cut into 1-inch cubes. Stir together potato and egg. Stir together mayonnaise and next 3 ingredients; gently stir into potato mixture. Serve immediately, or cover and chill, if desired.
This post was edited on 1/20/25 at 2:40 pm
Posted on 1/19/25 at 4:53 pm to Tiger328
I make mine like the one LouisanaLady posted below.
I like a pretty plain potato salad with a good bit of eggs and mustard, and always a good quality mayo. Either Blueplate or Hellmans.
I like a pretty plain potato salad with a good bit of eggs and mustard, and always a good quality mayo. Either Blueplate or Hellmans.
Popular
Back to top
7








