Ok, I didn't see the match, but I have seen the replay various times and I think it was a bad red. Nani was looking at the ball and anyone with eyes can see that he didn't know that player was coming at him. He was trying to control the ball, which isn't that extraordinary for Nani's skill set. The play could have been looked at as dangerous, but I still think it's yellow at worst. This ref has a history against England and EPL teams. He sent off Terry against Barcelona in last years CL. He sent off Cahill in the Club World Cup final which was horrible. He sent off Balotelli in the Europa. He sent off an England player in WCQ and 2 English players in U21 Euros. All that said, F Man U. If it's anything it's a Karma Red.