Started By
Message
locked post

Current idea that cold is from global warming fundamentally flawed?

Posted on 1/11/14 at 8:05 am
Posted by KnoxvilleBerryTiger
Member since Mar 2006
3412 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 8:05 am
So, I never heard of the polar vortex before this cold snap.

In hearing that the cold temperatures could be from global warming that has resulted in melting of arctic ice, and then learning that arctic ice has increases profoundly in recent years, I read up on it a bit and came away with questions.

How is this theory not an outright lie?

How can you theorize that the cause is from melting, when it's been freezing now in a remarkable way?

In the 2 minute video below, the guy talks about increased warming relative to other latitudes. So, is it a relative air temperature difference that they are basing this on? Is there an air temperature component that is warming, that exists even with the gain in sea ice? (I could not find data on arctic air temperature patterns.)

Is there a chronological component to this that I am not aware of, thus this exists because of previous warming?

Are they disputing that ice is increasing?

Links for reference
LINK

LINK

LINK
This post was edited on 1/11/14 at 8:19 am
Posted by samson'sseed
Augusta
Member since Aug 2013
2070 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 9:47 am to
It's not a lie that global warming can cause a sudden onset of cold climate.

It is a geological fact.

I'm not well versed on the polar vortex, but I have thoroughly studied Ice Age climates. Studying paleoecology is a hobby of mine.

Toward the end of the last Ice Age, natural forcing caused average annual temperatures to rise suddenly. This caused rapid melting of glacial ice. This cold meltwater became locked behind giant ice dams. When thes ice dams burst, billions of gallons of cold freshwater plus ice bergs and rafted debris flooded into the North Atlantic. This huge amount of cold freshwater shut down thermohaline circulation--the ocean currents that moderate climates.

This caused a sudden drop in worldwide average annual temperatures precipitating a 1500 year cold snap known as the Younger Dryas--it became as cold as the Ice Age again.

This cyclical event has occurred multiple times over the last 7 millions years, but especially over the last 2.4 million years. It happens more frequently and with greater intensity during Ice Ages.

There is abundant geological evidence of these events, known as Heinrich Events. At the bottom of the ocean there are rocks called dropstones and lots of debris including fossil trees that were carried out to sea by these floods. There are even visible drag marks off the coast of South Carolina where icebergs half ran aground on the ocean bottom.
Posted by fleaux
section 0
Member since Aug 2012
8741 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 9:55 am to
So the earth heals itself, right?? What arrogant fools we would be to mess with the Earth's natural cycles
Posted by DCRebel
An office somewhere
Member since Aug 2009
17644 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 9:59 am to
While we were experiencing the polar vortex, Australia was experiencing a record heat wave.

There's a reason it's called global climate change.
Posted by KnoxvilleBerryTiger
Member since Mar 2006
3412 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 10:07 am to
I am not disputing or supporting the idea that global warming could make areas colder.

What I want to know is if those stating that this cold IS ,in fact, from warming, what warming are they basing this on? What I am reading states that the area in question is cooling, or more specifically increasing in freezing.

What measure are they using to support that this is from warming that I do not see?
Posted by Tigah in the ATL
Atlanta
Member since Feb 2005
27539 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 12:17 pm to
Good grief. Weather is not climate and the singular of data isn't anecdote.
Posted by Zach
Gizmonic Institute
Member since May 2005
112385 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 12:29 pm to
quote:

There's a reason it's called normal climate fluctuations.


Fify
Posted by League Champs
Bayou Self
Member since Oct 2012
10340 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 1:12 pm to
quote:

This cold meltwater became locked behind giant ice dams. When thes ice dams burst, billions of gallons of cold freshwater plus ice bergs and rafted debris flooded into the North Atlantic.

I read about that somewhere. Some guy named Noah. There's a movie about it coming out in March
quote:

This cyclical event has occurred multiple times over the last 7 millions years, but especially over the last 2.4 million years. It happens more frequently and with greater intensity during Ice Ages.

And what was missing during those ages?

Hmmm?

Humans!

So, technically it should be called Earthmade global warming (and cooling, it now appears)
Posted by Strannix
District 11
Member since Dec 2012
48832 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 1:37 pm to
quote:

While we were experiencing the polar vortex, Australia was experiencing a record heat wave.

There's a reason it's called global climate change.

there is no reasoning with the extreme low information person like yourself
Posted by KnoxvilleBerryTiger
Member since Mar 2006
3412 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 5:23 pm to
Role of man aside, is this theory completely bogus?

This post was edited on 1/11/14 at 5:24 pm
Posted by Hoyas
Member since Sep 2013
2478 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 7:24 pm to
Good Grief

The earth has cycles and mans affect is minimal.
Posted by GeauxxxTigers23
TeamBunt General Manager
Member since Apr 2013
62514 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 7:32 pm to
If "global warming" or "climate change" were man made, what realistically could be done to stop it at this point? And if it could be stopped, what are taxes going to do to stop it? We obviously don't need to research it anymore because I've been told numerous times that it is a scientifically proven fact already.

The simple fact is is that the left doesn't give two shits about stopping "climate change." If they did they would just make a law shutting down all harmful pollutants in the country. And then force developing countries to stop polluting as well. Of course they would just tell us to frick off because not everyone is stupid enough to just shut down their economy to save the planet.

But it's the planet we're talking about!!!! Are we going to use military force to stop people from driving cars and shut down all the power plants. It would definitely be worth the blood and treasure. We only have one Earth after all. Nothing should be off the table.
Posted by NC_Tigah
Carolinas
Member since Sep 2003
123756 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 7:50 pm to
quote:

Toward the end of the last Ice Age, natural forcing caused average annual temperatures to rise suddenly.
What was the source of this "natural forcing"?
Posted by TrueTiger
Chicken's most valuable
Member since Sep 2004
67606 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 9:01 pm to
The idea that humans have enough power to destroy the earth is laughable.

We aren't much more than giant ants, not gods.

Get over yourselves.

Posted by drizztiger
Deal With it!
Member since Mar 2007
36778 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 9:44 pm to
quote:

The idea that humans have enough power to destroy the earth is laughable.
Dumb is dumb.
Posted by McLemore
Member since Dec 2003
31421 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 11:08 pm to
quote:

what are taxes going to do to stop it


especially considering China, Russia and other countries with huge populations, significant landmass, and no reason to listen to the US or our allies are polluting exponentially more than we are. (sorry, i replied before finishing your whole post, where you touch on this.)
This post was edited on 1/11/14 at 11:10 pm
Posted by StrangeBrew
Salvation Army-Thanks Obama
Member since May 2009
18183 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 11:14 pm to
If we could just figure out how to keep the sun at one level output versus these unnatural flares.
Posted by kingbob
Sorrento, LA
Member since Nov 2010
66982 posts
Posted on 1/11/14 at 11:24 pm to
The theory of warming triggering major cooling has to do with two interrelated parts of the earth's climatic system: salinity and heat flow in the atlantic ocean.

The theory revolves around what is known as the north atlantic conveyer system (of which the gulf stream is a part) which consists of ocean currents that take warm air from the tropics north towards Iceland which then sinks as it cools and flows back south. This helps to keep temperatures more mild in the northern Europe and Canada than they would be otherwise. What allows this to happen is that salinity varies both in temperature and depth and has a huge effect on buoyancy (for example, you are far more buoyant in the Dead Sea than in a fresh water lake). This allows the cold water to sink beneath the warm and flow south.

The theory as related to global warming states that as temperatures across the world increase, more arctic ice will melt, adding more freshwater to the north Atlantic Ocean. This change in salinity will reach a tipping point where the cold water will no longer be able to sink beneath the warm water mass and flow south, causing the conveyor to grind to a halt.

Without this flow of energy, Europe and North America get colder and wetter while the tropics get hotter and dryer. This has been observed at times throughout the ice ages.

The fear is that man is contributing to warming, therefor accelerating the process. Personally, i think man-driven agw is hogwash thanks to my knowledge of climate and modeling techniques.
Posted by samson'sseed
Augusta
Member since Aug 2013
2070 posts
Posted on 1/12/14 at 8:29 am to
Orbital variations that alter the amount of solar radiation reaching earth.
Posted by TejasHorn
High Plains Driftin'
Member since Mar 2007
10869 posts
Posted on 1/12/14 at 8:31 am to
quote:

The idea that humans have enough power to destroy the earth is laughable.


Wow. I'm glad this attitude is rare outside of the poli board.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram