Which Fincher film did you enjoy more, Seven or Gone Girl?

I dunno ever since Saw, Seven's just been so-so to me.

Seven is one of my favorites.

damn I need to see GG if it's as good as seven. Still havne't gotten around to it yet.

I have not seen it in quite a while, but seven was much better than GG for me. I am not as big on GG as others on this board though. Did not love.

I saw Seven when I was in high school. It was with some friends. We were all pretty freaked out and talked about it(like HSers do) for a couple weeks.

I saw Gone Girl and thought it was good and well made.

But I will always think Seven is better because of the impact the film had on me at the time. Im catholic so religious themes have always piqued my interest.

that isn't to say one is better then the other. Seven had better timing for me.

Now if I was in a loveless marriage / was banging some 19 YO / would fear for my life if she ever found out, I would probably relate more to Gone Girl.

Love them both, but I absolutely love how Fincher directs Gone Girl. He makes the story very pure on screen. It almost seems like the background is hollow, so we can focus on the main story. It's hard to explain, but I was grinning ear to ear the first time I saw it.

Seven.

quote:

---

Both really well acted and of course the cast of Se7en was incredible with Freeman, Pitt and Spacey.

---

Se7en was incredible about setting a specific mood.

Raining the whole time and just the look of the film is incredible.

Both were great films, but Se7en is an all time great.

"Whats in the box!!!!???"

Seven

I loved both. I haven't seen Seven in awhile so it's tough to compare. Gone Girl was a well constructed wild ride. He definately feels as though he has gotten better over the years. He has said that he can't watch Seven without cringing, whatever that means.