Which PI rule do you favor? College or NFL?

College.

/thread.

easily college

College by a mile.

The best PI possible would be a combination of the two. It should be 15 yards unless it's a flagrant, deliberate mugging, which should be a spot foul. Kinda like running into the kicker or roughing the kicker.

college

way too costly in the NFL

College. NFL rewards a terrible decision by a QB to throw into coverage way too much. A lot of the calls are questionable at best to reward a bad play with big yardage.

quote:

---

The best PI possible would be a combination of the two. It should be 15 yards unless it's a flagrant, deliberate mugging, which should be a spot foul. Kinda like running into the kicker or roughing the kicker.

---

I actually kinda agree with this. Something like this:

is probably worthy of spot of the foul, but in most cases the penalty doesn't fit the crime and is too harsh

College. Especially the way the game is played today.

I like college but I don't like the fact that DBs can just commit the penalty when they're beat. I agree with the idea of a combo. If it's obviously deliberate, spot foul.

I like the NFL rule because if the PI doesn't happen, most likely the receiver makes the catch.

So if it's only a 15 yard penalty on a 40 yard throw, the offense loses a potential 25 yards or more after the catch.

So the NFL rule fits the crime in my opinion.

quote:

---

I like the NFL rule because if the PI doesn't happen, most likely the receiver makes the catch.

So if it's only a 15 yard penalty on a 40 yard throw, the offense loses a potential 25 yards or more after the catch.

---

I used to agree with this until the pussification of the football. Now I prefer the college rule considering how often they call pi.