Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message
locked post

The age of white guilt: and the disappearance of the black individual

Posted on 6/24/14 at 8:56 am
Posted by Jimbeaux
Member since Sep 2003
20102 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 8:56 am
Though published in Harper's Magazine in 1999, and I'm sure it's been posted hereabouts over the years, this essay by Shelby Steele remains as one of the most insightful and thought provoking articles on the topic of "race relations in the U.S." ever written.

I stumbled across it again recently and thought it was worth sharing. If you've read it before, it's worth reading again!

LINK

quote:

He is a figure of pathos because his faith in racial victimization is his only release from racial shame.


quote:

The greatest problem in coming from an oppressed group is the power the oppressor has over your group. The second greatest problem is the power your group has over you. Group identity in oppressed groups is always very strategic, always a calculation of advantage. The humble black identity of the Booker T. Washington era--"a little education spoiled many a good plow hand"--allowed blacks to function as tradesmen, laborers, and farmers during the rise of Jim Crow, when hundreds of blacks were being lynched yearly. Likewise, the black militancy of the late sixties strategically aimed for advantage in an America suddenly contrite over its long indulgence in racism.


quote:

Today the protest identity is a career advantage for an entire generation of black intellectuals, particularly academics who have been virtually forced to position themselves in the path of their university's obsession with "diversity." Inflation from the moral authority of protest, added to the racialpreference policies in so many American institutions, provides an irresistible incentive for black America's best minds to continue defining themselves by protest. Professors who resist the Baldwin model risk the Ellisonian fate of invisibility.




quote:

Two great, immutable forces have driven America's attitudes, customs, and public policies around race. The first has been white racism, and the second has been white guilt. The civil-rights movement was the dividing line between the two. Certainly there was some guilt before this movement, and no doubt some racism remains after it. But the great achievement of the civil-rights movement was that its relentless moral witness finally defeated the legitimacy of racism as propriety--a principle of social organization, manners, and customs that defines decency itself. An idea controls culture when it achieves the invisibility of propriety. And it must be remembered that racism was a propriety, a form of decency. When, as a boy, I was prohibited from entering the fine Christian home of the occasional white playmate, it was to save the household an indecency. Today, thanks to the civil-rights movement, white guilt is propriety--an utterly invisible code that defines decency in our culture with thousands of little protocols we no longer even think about. We have been living in an age of white guilt for four decades now.


Wow. What an amazing insight. We've seen the same lightning-fast "change in propriety" over the gay rights movement in the past couple of years.
This post was edited on 6/24/14 at 9:33 am
Posted by Beachtiger
Bomba Shack
Member since Apr 2007
4130 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 9:13 am to
Post to read later.
Posted by Jimbeaux
Member since Sep 2003
20102 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 9:37 am to
Another amazing quote from the article:

quote:

People often deny white guilt by pointing to its irrationality--"I never owned a slave," "My family got here eighty years after slavery was over." But of course almost nothing having to do with race is rational. That whites are now stigmatized by their race is not poetic justice; it is simply another echo of racism's power to contaminate by mere association.
Posted by Jimbeaux
Member since Sep 2003
20102 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 9:57 pm to
Bump for night crew.

Do you think things have changed any since 1999?

It seems that official Affirmative Action programs on the decline, especially relative to court rulings on college admission policies, but victim politics and the age of white guilt is as strong as ever.
Posted by Roger Klarvin
DFW
Member since Nov 2012
46505 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 10:10 pm to
Whites arent stigmatized in this country. Certain white people who believe certain things and act in a certain way are stigmatized. That doesnt mean that its always a justified or deserved stigma, but the original premise of this thread is flawed.
Posted by Jimbeaux
Member since Sep 2003
20102 posts
Posted on 6/24/14 at 10:48 pm to
Did you read the essay?
Posted by Hog on the Hill
AR
Member since Jun 2009
13389 posts
Posted on 6/25/14 at 6:44 am to
quote:

We've seen the same lightning-fast "change in propriety" over the gay rights movement in the past couple of years.
I wouldn't say "a couple years", I'd say several decades. But you're right that it's a relatively fast change as far as culture is concerned.

But what does this have to do with what the author is saying about the propriety of racism? I'm not sure I follow.

(I did read the essay, fwiw. It is a good and thought-provoking read)
This post was edited on 6/25/14 at 6:45 am
Posted by Jimbeaux
Member since Sep 2003
20102 posts
Posted on 6/25/14 at 7:49 am to
quote:

But what does this have to do with what the author is saying about the propriety of racism? I'm not sure I follow.


You're right, it certainly is a tangent off the main theme of the essay, but I found his terminology and identification of the concept of "propriety" to be fascinating.

It's another, perhaps more precise, way of discussing "collective conscience", or "public opinion", or "mores".

There can be an actual tipping point and then a watershed switch in the public view of a topic, once it is seen as "the proper way".

I think this phenomenon has strengthened with increased communications across a society. It happens with generally small issues as well as big social movements. It appears to be precipitated by subtle comments and innuendos more so than by pronouncements and laws beings passed.

I think that this effect is being seized upon by political operatives as an effective tool in shaping society to their way of thinking. Both sides try it, but lately, the progressives have shown to be more masterful at it.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram