Max the 401K vs Roth | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
MDTiger 13
LSU Fan
Brandon, MS
Member since Nov 2010
522 posts

Max the 401K vs Roth



Good evening MT board. I'm as green as you can be in the investing world seeing as how I've been in school for the past 21 years and finally have a job that is allowing me to think outside of the month-to-month box. I have a question about what you recommend for someone with a little extra cash. My current 401K is mandatory and pretty great. I give 9% of salary and they give 12%. However, I will only average about 10K per year doing this without pushing more in myself. I currently qualify for a Roth but do not have one, and I qualify for no more than 3 more years, if not less. Which would the MT recommend I do. Max out the 401K or open and max a Roth for the next 1-3 years? Please bear with me if this is a dumb question. I'm trying to read and further my knowledge in investing, but, as I said, still very new to it all.






Back to top
Share:
Teddy Ruxpin
LSU Fan
New Orleans, LA
Member since Oct 2006
19341 posts
 Online 

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Put enough in to get company match, then max the Roth is what I usually see around here





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Lsut81
USA Fan
Member since Jun 2005
64934 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Go to employer match and then max out Roth first.





Back to top
nelatf
Louisiana Tech Fan
NELA
Member since Jan 2011
1204 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Max out 401k for the match - then Roth.





Back to top
LSUtigerME
LSU Fan
Walker, LA
Member since Oct 2012
644 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Are you implying your contribution alone is only $9k, or yours + match?

If yours alone, I'd suggest contributing more to the pre-tax 401k. This is based on the likelihood of being in a lower tax bracket at retirement, since it is likely higher now. That is something for you to evaluate. Do you expect to "make" more income in retirement than you do today?

However, you may also wish to tax diversify for retirement, in which case you should do both. 401k up to match, max Roth IRA, then any extra back to 401k.

Is the 3 year limit based on projected income?






Back to top
  Replies (0)
MDTiger 13
LSU Fan
Brandon, MS
Member since Nov 2010
522 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


There is no maxing out to get the match. It is an involuntary 9% of my salary and is matched with 12% of my salary from employer. Increasing my contribution would just be money going unmatched into my plan. Sounds like the Roth is the way to go





Back to top
RIPMachoMan
LSU Fan
Nola
Member since Jun 2011
1012 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


They call it a match by giving you 12% to your 9%? I'd double check to make sure you don't need to increase your contribution to 12% to get their max of 12%.





Back to top
MDTiger 13
LSU Fan
Brandon, MS
Member since Nov 2010
522 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Yes, they give 12 to my 9%. I can give more, but 9% is mandatory minimum and that is what gets the 12.





Back to top
slackster
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Mar 2009
6370 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

Yes, they give 12 to my 9%. I can give more, but 9% is mandatory minimum and that is what gets the 12.


I'm in the wrong fricking business then.

My employer matches 50 cents on the dollar for up to 3% of salary, then that is it. I put in 15% and get a match of 1.5%. It blows.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Oenophile Brah
LSU Fan
The Edge of Sanity
Member since Jan 2013
5320 posts
 Online 

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

Yes, they give 12 to my 9%.

Not uncommon in certain fields.

quote:

MDTiger 13

New Doc?






Back to top
RIPMachoMan
LSU Fan
Nola
Member since Jun 2011
1012 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Damn that's a good deal. to the free money brotha!





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Hawkeye95
Iowa Fan
Member since Dec 2013
3676 posts
 Online 

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


i would max out the 401k. I do not believe for a second that roth distributions will be tax free when I retire.







Back to top
tirebiter
LSU Fan
ATL
Member since Oct 2006
5190 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

Max out the 401K or open and max a Roth for the next 1-3 years? Please bear with me if this is a dumb question. I'm trying to read and further my knowledge in investing, but, as I said, still very new to it all.


Being that you will likely be in a much higher tax bracket after 3 years I would advocate contributing to a Roth the next 3 years. After that max the 401k, then contribute to a non-deductible traditional IRA if desired and convert those contributions to a Roth. If you have additional free cash flow you could also up your 401k contributions YRs 1-3 as well.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
nelatf
Louisiana Tech Fan
NELA
Member since Jan 2011
1204 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

i would max out the 401k. I do not believe for a second that roth distributions will be tax free when I retire.


Well hell.....you just pissed in my Cheerios.



But you may be right - had counted on those Roth distributions to be tax free when I am an old man.






Back to top
Oenophile Brah
LSU Fan
The Edge of Sanity
Member since Jan 2013
5320 posts
 Online 

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

i would max out the 401k. I do not believe for a second that roth distributions will be tax free when I retire.

I think it's unlikely all Roth contributions will eventually be taxed. I could see the government put a cap on tax free gains at some point.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
MDTiger 13
LSU Fan
Brandon, MS
Member since Nov 2010
522 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

New Doc?


Indeed. My residency program has a sweet retirement plan. I kept thinking I'd heard them wrong during our orientation until I got home and started reading all of the info.

quote:

i would max out the 401k. I do not believe for a second that roth distributions will be tax free when I retire.


I was introduced to Roth's because my wife has had one for years that her parents set up for her. From day 1 I've told her it will be taxed more, and she think's I'm crazy...






Back to top
slackster
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Mar 2009
6370 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

From day 1 I've told her it will be taxed more, and she think's I'm crazy...


Meh, I'm not as pessimistic as you apparently. I believe that if/when the Roth protections go away, those who have them will be grandfathered in under the old rules. We may never even get to that point though.






Back to top
TheIndulger
Longwood Fan
Member since Sep 2011
10628 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


quote:

Go to employer match then max out roth IRA


Isn't this only beneficial if the tax rate increases before you retire?






Back to top
ell_13
USA Fan
Alex Box
Member since Apr 2013
24538 posts
 Online 

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Or you are in a higher tax bracket when you retire. It's best if you're in a low tax bracket now.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
jso0003
Auburn Fan
Birmingham/Atlanta
Member since Jun 2009
4884 posts

re: Max the 401K vs Roth


Yea, you're already chunking a good bit into 401k with those percentages.

I say max the Roth now while you can because once you're done with residency and making the big bucks you'll probably be ineligible to contribute to the Roth.






Back to top


Back to top