Started By
Message

Movies That Are Better Than The Book

Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:14 am
Posted by elprez00
Hammond, LA
Member since Sep 2011
29350 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:14 am
So often here I see comments such as "the book was better". (I make them too.) Its rare that Hollywood can take a story in print and translate it effectively to the screen. So lets talk about times when Hollywood gets it right.

The Godfather is probably going to be a popular choice, but I can't comment because I've never read it.

Mine by far is The Natural. I loved baseball as a kid, and The Natural is arguably one of the greatest baseball movies ever made. Roy running the bases after hitting the homerun as the sparks rain down. (The music is playing through your head right now, isn't it?)

About 10 years ago, I picked up the book by Bernard Malamud. Spoilers below.

The movie follows the first half of the book almost word for word. Then, right after Roy becomes the starter after Bump dies, the movie deviates completely. In the book, Roy uses his success to get the Judge to give him more money. When the Judge refuses, Max prints a story about it and the fans hate the Judge for it. Iris is not Roy's childhood girlfriend, he meets her much later when she stands up during his slump. But the worst part of all: Roy accepts the bribe, even asking for more money. He's in the process of throwing the game until he fouls off the pitch that breaks Wonderboy and hits Iris. She tells him shes pregnant. Roy has a change of heart, only to strike out during the final at bat. Max learns of Roys past, and the bribe, prints it, and Roy is banned from baseball forever.

No offense, but that movie would've sucked had it ended like that.

What say you, M/TV Board?
Posted by LSUPERMAN
Louisiana
Member since Aug 2007
2457 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:17 am to
The Shining. Didn't like the ending in the book.
Posted by Freauxzen
Utah
Member since Feb 2006
37223 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:29 am to
The Mist
Posted by Kafka
I am the moral conscience of TD
Member since Jul 2007
141386 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:29 am to
Cape Fear (original!!!)

The film was based on the novel The Executioners by John D. McDonald (highly regarded for his Travis McGee detective series).

The book is not about two men facing off against one another. It's actually about the lawyer and his wife. The Max Cady villain character only appears once, very briefly.

And the book has virtually no action. It consists almost entirely of conversations between the lawyer and wife discussing what they should do. Even the big climax when Cady is killed happens "off screen", and the couple then goes to the scene to see what happened.
Posted by likeaboss
Destrehan, LA
Member since Sep 2012
227 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:31 am to
Fight Club
Posted by elprez00
Hammond, LA
Member since Sep 2011
29350 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:42 am to
quote:

Fight Club

Really? Fight Club is almost a word for word adaptation of the book. Hell, the dialogue almost reads like a screenplay.

Plus, the book has the extra scene at the hospital at the end.

Edit: I'm not hating, thats just an odd choice.
This post was edited on 1/20/14 at 8:43 am
Posted by Rex
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
66001 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:42 am to
"Jaws" is the most obvious answer.
Posted by WhoDats10
Member since Dec 2012
1580 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:44 am to
lord of the rings
Posted by BOSCEAUX
Where the Down Boys go.
Member since Mar 2008
47709 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:46 am to
Stand by Me. Took a King short story and knocked it out of the park.
Posted by hobotiger
Asbury Park, NJ
Member since Nov 2007
5191 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:48 am to
I personally did not like how they changed the ending in The Natural
Posted by elprez00
Hammond, LA
Member since Sep 2011
29350 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:48 am to
quote:

lord of the rings

1000 pages.

quote:

jaws

Rex, I've had Peter Benchley's novel sitting on my bookshelf for years and have never read it.

quote:

Stand by Me

great answer.


I'm really surprised no one has said Forrest Gump.
Posted by AgGator
Member since Nov 2009
130 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:52 am to
I was just about to say Forrest Gump. After growing up with the movie, and loving it, the book had too many major differences for me to accept. I just couldn't wrap my head around bubba being white.

If you think about it the book was really like three Tom Hanks movies in one. Forrest Gump, Apollo 13, and Cast Away
Posted by LordoftheManor
Member since Jul 2006
8371 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 8:55 am to
The Godfather. Good book, brilliant film.
Posted by thekid
Anna, Tx
Member since May 2006
3936 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:01 am to
Shawshank redemption...
The book is a Stephen King short story and the movie is better...
Posted by tylerdurden24
Member since Sep 2009
46385 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:14 am to
Fight Club. Even Chuck Palahniuk thinks the movie is better (and the book isn't bad by any stretch; the movie is just that good)
Posted by PillageUrVillage
Mordor
Member since Mar 2011
14715 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:17 am to
quote:

lord of the rings


Posted by jose canseco
Houston via Houma via BR via NOLA
Member since Jul 2007
5667 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:24 am to
10 Commandments
Posted by elprez00
Hammond, LA
Member since Sep 2011
29350 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:28 am to
quote:

Even Chuck Palahniuk thinks the movie is better (and the book isn't bad by any stretch; the movie is just that good)

I still say this is like asking which is better, a bone in ribeye or filet. No matter which you choose, you're going to be satisfied.

The movie is one of my favorites; and after reading the book the movie impressed me even more with the way they were able to do Tyler/Narrators interactions.

The foreword by Chuck in the edition of Fight Club I have is priceless. He tells a story about a horseback riding trip where the guide makes a First Rule reference. Afterwords he tells the guy "I'm the guy that wrote the book." Guide responds, "They made a book out of that movie?"
Posted by Cockopotamus
Member since Jan 2013
15736 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:33 am to
I think part of this has to do with whether you read the book or watched the movie first.

I'll say No Country for Old Men
Posted by Napoleon
Kenna
Member since Dec 2007
69040 posts
Posted on 1/20/14 at 9:36 am to
quote:

I was just about to say Forrest Gump. After growing up with the movie, and loving it, the book had too many major differences for me to accept. I just couldn't wrap my head around bubba being white.

If you think about it the book was really like three Tom Hanks movies in one. Forrest Gump, Apollo 13, and Cast Away


In the second Forrest Gump book, Forrest plays for the New Orleans Saints.

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 6Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram