Posted byMessage
AlienYall
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Dec 2013
127 posts

Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


figured I would compare these two cats since they both have movies coming out right about now and are pretty much the same age (39 years old and about two weeks apart). they both grew up in the industry and also have the same three types of Oscar nominations as well (2 Lead, 1 Supporting) -


Joaquin Phoenix

Best Actor in a Supporting Role - Gladiator (2000)

Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role - Walk the Line (2005)

Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role - The Master (2012)


Leonardo DiCaprio


Best Actor in a Supporting Role - What's Eating Gilbert Grape (1993)

Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role - The Aviator (2004)

Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role - Blood Diamond (2006)



Leo is obviously the popular choice, but I think ole Joaquin puts in that work even if most his movies aren't as mainstream. I'm going with Joaquin.







Back to top
Share:
Funky Tide 8
Alabama Fan
Tittleman's Crest
Member since Feb 2009
25479 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


quote:

Leo






Back to top
Henry Jones Jr
Virginia Fan
Picture me rollin'
Member since Jun 2011
21667 posts
 Online 

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo and it's not even close.

I know this is a terrible thing to say but I can't take Phoenix seriously with that cleft lip scar. It's too damn distracting.






Back to top
weaveballs1
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Jun 2010
1197 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo.

The thing where Phoenix went all awol for that mockumentary thing was beyond stupid.






Back to top
RollTide1987
Alabama Fan
Pensacola, Florida
Member since Nov 2009
22699 posts
 Online 

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


I actually think they're about equal.

Joaquin Phoenix is more of a method actor whereas Leo uses his charisma to drive his roles.

Phoenix's performances are more low-key while Leo's are very in your face.

They both are excellent at what they do.

I think Leo will get more votes because he's the bigger box office draw.







Back to top
Kafka
New Orleans Saints Fan
too wrong; didn't lead
Member since Jul 2007
68553 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


quote:

these two cats






Back to top
AlienYall
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Dec 2013
127 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


quote:

I think Leo will get more votes because he's the bigger box office draw.


truth.

hence why I asked "who is the more talented actor?" because of that reason.






Back to top
RonBurgundy
LSU Fan
Whale's Vagina(San Diego)
Member since Oct 2005
8847 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo has more Oscar snubs than Phoenix has great performances(and I am fan of Joaquin)...Look at his body of work. Blood Diamond is one of the very few films he was nominated for and its not even his top 5(which are The Departed, Aviator, Gilbert, Catch Me and Shutter Island)*

*have not seen Wolf yet






Back to top
SoFla Tideroller
Alabama Fan
South Florida
Member since Apr 2010
4505 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


I know this is a terrible thing to say but I can't take Phoenix seriously with that cleft lip scar. It's too damn distracting.

And his deformed, bowed in chest








Back to top
betweenthebara
Texas A&M Fan
California
Member since May 2013
2389 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


the collective hard-on this board has for dicraprio is hilarious.


Joaquin. Not close. The end.

Sorry. I'm not sorry.



This post was edited on 12/28 at 6:14 am


Back to top
molsusports
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2004
26262 posts
 Online 

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


He's not the box office draw or the mega-millionaire that Leo is but the answer is Joaquin Phoenix





Back to top
Gnar Cat21
Auburn Fan
Piña Coladaburg
Member since Sep 2009
10339 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


I love Leo but it's Joaquin and it's not really close


edit: ok sorry, it's close



This post was edited on 12/28 at 7:19 am


Back to top
donRANDOMnumbers
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Lafayette Rouge
Member since Nov 2006
11726 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


I love Insert name

But it's Insert name

And it's not even close.



Anyone else?






Back to top
Gnar Cat21
Auburn Fan
Piña Coladaburg
Member since Sep 2009
10339 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


do you want me to do a fricking breakdown or something?

i edited so your little leo feeling weren't hurt



This post was edited on 12/28 at 7:13 am


Back to top
Freauxzen
USA Fan
Louisiana
Member since Feb 2006
19724 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


quote:

Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


It isn't a specific question, and finding an answer is difficult. You could say, who's the better movie star? (Leo) Who's got the bigger range? (Leo) Who's more intense? (Phoenix) Who disappears more into his roles? (Phoenix)

For this:

quote:

talented actor?


I'd probably say Phoenix. He's more out of the Brando, Mifune, Kinski feel of acting. His performance in The Master is better than anything Leo has done.






Back to top
rondo
New Orleans Saints Fan
Worst. Poster. Evar.
Member since Jan 2004
58463 posts
 Online 

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Whichever one has made less movies about falling in love with siri


This post was edited on 12/28 at 7:52 am


Back to top
trom83
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Oct 2013
1114 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


quote:

Joaquin Phoenix


Before he jumped off the deep end. Leonardo DiCaprio isn't that bad of an actor though.He was incredible in The Departed.






Back to top
Brosef Stalin
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2011
6855 posts
 Online 

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo is a decent actor but highly overrated. He was the worst part of Gangs of New York.





Back to top
HoustonGumbeauxGuy
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2011
4835 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo is good, but I struggle with his capabilities of mastering differing roles.

Joaquin Phoenix and Johnny Depp are much more impressive to me. They do a better job of changing up their acting style for each role they get into.

Leo is pretty much the same every time.






Back to top
BCMCubs
LSU Fan
Colorado
Member since Nov 2011
4378 posts

re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?


Leo.

I'm amazed that he doesn't have an Oscar for best actor






Back to top



Back to top