Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?



So in lieu of our game tomorrow vs the Terps, my roommates (MD fans) are saying Edsall is a better coach than Holgo. Naturally, I disagree.

Who would you rather have as a head coach at your school?







Back to top
Share:
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187260 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Neither. Both are average





Back to top
Tigertown in ATL
LSU Fan
Atlanta/Savannah
Member since Sep 2009
11520 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Holgo


POS

so anyone else






Back to top
Paul Allen
USA Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Nov 2007
29350 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Eds





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Neither. Both are average


If you had to pick one. If not you get stuck with Charlie Weis






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

POS



Why do you think Holgo is a POS?






Back to top
TigerintheNO
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jan 2004
23044 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


I really don't think either is going to be successful in their current situation.

Now if I had to answer
quote:

Who would you rather have as a head coach at your school?


I would chose Edsall, for LSU.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Tigertown in ATL
LSU Fan
Atlanta/Savannah
Member since Sep 2009
11520 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Why do you think Holgo is a POS?


I don't believe he was the victim in the whole Bill Stewart exodus.






Back to top
tigerfan84
Wake Forest Fan
Member since Dec 2003
5949 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Holgorsen and then hire a quality D Coordinator





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

I don't believe he was the victim in the whole Bill Stewart exodus.


As a preface, Bill Stewart should have never been hired as the HC. It was a drunken, emotional decision by the previous AD at WVU after an emotional Fiesta Bowl win against OU.

Oliver Luck came in and realized Stewart was chopped liver. He tried to do the coach in waiting thing instead of just firing Stewart. Stewart and his wife got pissed because an "outsider" was going to become coach and he told reporters to "dig up dirt" on Holgo.

Stew was running WVU into the ground. Rich Rod built WV into a top 10-15 program,and Stewart ran that shite into the ground. When Holgo took over, WVU had 68 kids on scholarship.

Stewart also tried to make Pat White, arguably the best running QB of all time, a fricking pocket passer



This post was edited on 9/20 at 7:41 pm


Back to top
Tigertown in ATL
LSU Fan
Atlanta/Savannah
Member since Sep 2009
11520 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Sevendust912


You know more about it than I of course.

I never said Stewart was good, but WVU is worse now than when LSU was drilling them.







Back to top
Carson123987
LSU Fan
Middle Court at the Rec
Member since Jul 2011
37890 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Neither






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Franktowntiger7
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2010
1844 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Played for Holgerson, he is a dick.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
SM6
Navy Fan
Chicago
Member since Jul 2008
6362 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Edsall.. hes not rapey




This post was edited on 9/20 at 7:53 pm


Back to top
LSUballs
LA-Monroe Fan
RayVegas LA
Member since Feb 2008
21366 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Ass Holgorson as he was known back in his MC days. Unbelievable he's the head coach at a D1 college. Complete jackass. Hope he gets committed to psych word where he belongs.


*ward



This post was edited on 9/20 at 8:00 pm


Back to top
FootballNostradamus
Clemson Fan
Member since Nov 2009
13996 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


I think both are damn good coaches and will be successful soon.

Both hired absolute dumpster fires and have had to completely rebuild programs. People have no idea the country club atmosphere Fat Ralph was running at Maryland before he left.

Edsall has cleaned house, brought in legit talent, and were it not for having to start a MLB at QB last year in one of the most absurd string of injuries to one position as I've ever seen, would have been much better than their record depicted.

I'd take either, but put a gun to my head and I probably take Edsall.






Back to top
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

You know more about it than I of course.




Just like having good discussions. I think this one is interesting becaus DH and RE are polar opposites

quote:

I never said Stewart was good, but WVU is worse now than when LSU was drilling them.


I was so drunk in Baton Rouge in 2010 the only thing I remember is Geno trying to take the snap from his guard LSU fans were great

LSU in Morgantown 2011 was a good gzme until #17 returned that KO for a TD. That was Dana's 4th game as a HC and he called a decent game considering we had a true freshman walk-on starting at RB. Why did we have a true FR walk at RB? Thank Bill Stewart for under-recruiting.

That said, good luck to LSU this year. Your fans treated us awesome in Baton Rouge, from what I can remember






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sevendust912
West Virginia Fan
Baltimore Orioles Fan
Member since Jun 2013
6350 posts
 Online 

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Ass Holgorson as he was known back in his MC days. Unbelievable he's the head coach at a D1 college. Complete jackass. Hope he gets committed to psych word where he belongs


What da frick?

Did Holgo frick your wife or something? He yells on the sidelines, but he is not an ass






Back to top
  Replies (0)
saintsfan22
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
baton rouge
Member since May 2006
26671 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


quote:

Both hired absolute dumpster fires and have had to completely rebuild programs

When did Holgerson have to completely rebuild WVU?






Back to top
Bama Bird
Penn State Fan
Member since Mar 2013
12761 posts

re: Dana Holgorsen or Randy Edsall. Who would you rather have?


Randy Edsall by far





Back to top


Back to top