Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55583 posts

Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


I need an impact to get some shite broken free. I'm always in need of an impact but never actually gotten one. I don't have a compressor so I'm leaning electric. What are the cons of the electric?






Back to top
Share:
BourgsTheWord
Southeastern LA Fan
Member since Apr 2008
23243 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


Dewalt 18v cordless impact





Back to top
BourgsTheWord
Southeastern LA Fan
Member since Apr 2008
23243 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

What are the cons of the el tric?


That you don't have to buy a compressor.



This post was edited on 7/29 at 3:04 pm


Back to top
JAB528
LSU Fan
The Mexican Ocean
Member since Jun 2012
14705 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


Air.





Back to top
DonChowder
LSU Fan
Caulifornea
Member since Dec 2012
4533 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


Don't go cordless if you're buying an electric impact.
1/2" minimum.
PB Blaster is your friend.
So is the almighty oxy/acetylene wrench.

Now, go break some shite.






Back to top
4X4DEMON
Northwestern St. Fan
NWLA
Member since Dec 2007
11187 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


pneumatic is the way to go if you're willing to buy a compressor, if not then electric will work but dont buy cordless. A stubborn lug will drain that battery in a heartbeat.





Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55583 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


I can't do cordless. It seems ridiculous really. I would go wired. I never work anywhere I don't have an outlet. When I built my house I had hundreds of outlets put in damn near everywhere.





Back to top
4X4DEMON
Northwestern St. Fan
NWLA
Member since Dec 2007
11187 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


What exactly do you need an impact for anyway?





Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55583 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


Mostly rotating tires. But I also need to break some seats free and pull them out of a car.





Back to top
4X4DEMON
Northwestern St. Fan
NWLA
Member since Dec 2007
11187 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


gotcha, I dont have any experience with electric impacts since I've always had the use of the big compressor at my dads. I always thought the electric ones were under powered though.





Back to top
Ace Midnight
LSU Fan
Ball, LA - Home, Sweet Home
Member since Dec 2006
29074 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

pneumatic is the way to go if you're willing to buy a compressor, if not then electric will work but dont buy cordless. A stubborn lug will drain that battery in a heartbeat.


I'm sorry, but none of this makes any sense. If you want a proper impact, you need a pneumatic, compressor setup, etc.

But, if you're going elecrtric, there's no reason (in 2013) not to get the cordless, because you're going to have the flexibility to take it to a breakdown and use it there.

Corded, plug-in electric impact is clown shoes, IMHO.






Back to top
4X4DEMON
Northwestern St. Fan
NWLA
Member since Dec 2007
11187 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

pneumatic is the way to go if you're willing to buy a compressor, if not then electric will work but dont buy cordless. A stubborn lug will drain that battery in a heartbeat.




I'm sorry, but none of this makes any sense. If you want a proper impact, you need a pneumatic, compressor setup, etc.

But, if you're going elecrtric, there's no reason (in 2013) not to get the cordless, because you're going to have the flexibility to take it to a breakdown and use it there.

Corded, plug-in electric impact is clown shoes, IMHO.


What doesn't make sense? I said a pneumatic should be his first choice, but he had to be willing to buy the compressor also. And a cordless impact WILL run a battery down very quickly with a stubborn bolt. Assuming it's not damn near welded on there taking it off with a tire iron should work fine.






Back to top
BourgsTheWord
Southeastern LA Fan
Member since Apr 2008
23243 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

And a cordless impact WILL run a battery down very quickly with a stubborn bolt.

I doubt it, but that's why you keep a spare battery on the charge at all time.






Back to top
4X4DEMON
Northwestern St. Fan
NWLA
Member since Dec 2007
11187 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

that's why you keep a spare battery on the charge at all time.

Wouldn't need that extra battery with a corded model or pneumatic






Back to top
tehmidget
LSU Fan
Prairieville, LA
Member since May 2004
1183 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


LINK

I got a second hand one like that and it is great.

Nothing beats air tools if you are going to be working in a home shop.






Back to top
NYCAuburn
Auburn Fan
TD Platinum Membership
Member since Feb 2011
30746 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

But, if you're going elecrtric, there's no reason (in 2013) not to get the cordless, because you're going to have the flexibility to take it to a breakdown and use it there


If I'm not mistaken, even the new 20v dewalts have like 20% torque than the electric. good Pnuematics are also air hogs, you need a good compressor as well



This post was edited on 7/29 at 3:44 pm


Back to top
Ole Geauxt
LSU Fan
KnowLa.
Member since Dec 2007
36240 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

What are the pros of the electric?


You don't have a compressor.








Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55583 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


Good point. Maybe I'll just buy that $450 snap-on and break even after 23 tire rotations.





Back to top
NYCAuburn
Auburn Fan
TD Platinum Membership
Member since Feb 2011
30746 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

Maybe I'll just buy that $450 snap-on and break even after 23 tire rotations.


good god are they charging $450. Let me see if I can help a brother out. Are you stuck on Snap-On? would any of the offering from MAC or Matco work? look at all their specs. if you really want any of those I can help you out, with any brand.

ETA: looks its either $590 or $685, 6 series or 7 series 400lbs vs 450lbs

Matco has a good specs model, its inbetween the two snap on's @ @650 retail, not sure what MAC has, I cant find a catalog and their website sucks.



This post was edited on 7/29 at 4:10 pm


Back to top
Ole Geauxt
LSU Fan
KnowLa.
Member since Dec 2007
36240 posts

re: Which should I buy? Electric or Air Impact


quote:

Good point. Maybe I'll just buy that $450 snap-on and break even after 23 tire rotations.

Broke, go where u bought your tires and get em rotated for free and stay $450 ahead..






Back to top


Back to top




//