Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
weisertiger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles, LA
Member since Sep 2007
1925 posts

Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


The citica and the revo s are both 129.99, and the revo sx is 159.99.

I will be fishing mostly salt water. I don't finish enough to spend more than 160 on a reel, so no revo inshore or chronarch for me.

Does anybody have experience with any of these?

TIA







Back to top
Share:
laangler21
LSU Fan
On the lake.
Member since May 2012
2257 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I have used both the citica and S, I like them both for different things, citica is my cranking reel, s is better for worming IMO.






Back to top
LA444
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Jan 2013
79 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Citica

All I do is saltwater fishing and mostly out of a kayak so they see plenty of saltwater. Had a revo and they just arent made for the saltwater like a shimano. It got corroded within a year. If you look around you can sometimes find Citicas on sale around $100 also on ebay. I like my Citica as much as my curado I have






Back to top
  Replies (0)
boom roasted
Member since Sep 2010
14311 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Bought a Citica not too long ago. Nothing bad to say about it.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
The Last Coco
LSU Fan
On the water
Member since Mar 2009
2857 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


SX and it isn't even really close IMHO.

Here is one for $135 with free shipping on eBay:

Abu Garcia REVO SX - $135

ETA: The REVO S is a great reel too. But if you have the coin for the SX, go with it. If, however, you want to spend less here is the S for $108:

REVO S for $108



This post was edited on 5/2 at 10:22 am


Back to top
JAB528
LSU Fan
The Mexican Ocean
Member since Jun 2012
14781 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Out of those, the citica. I've had bad luck with the revos.





Back to top
DrTyger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles
Member since Oct 2009
21382 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


No experience with Citica, but anything Shimano I've ever had has been $$$.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
POONHOUND
LSU Fan
Member since Nov 2010
1047 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


All i use are citica and curado's. Can't really go wrong with either IF you take care of them(cleaning after saltwater trips, oiling bearings, etc.)





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Yewkindewit
LSU Fan
Near Birmingham, Alabama
Member since Apr 2012
5749 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


My boys have Revos and Shimanos. They seem to use the Revos more often but they bass fish and do freshwater only.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
ZacAttack
Auburn Fan
The Land Mass
Member since Oct 2012
3800 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


When in doubt, pick a Shimano.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
wild877
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2010
390 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I have no complaints with my shimano chronarch





Back to top
  Replies (0)
DonChowder
LSU Fan
Caulifornea
Member since Dec 2012
4671 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


quote:

I've had bad luck with the revos.
I hear this alot but I love mine. Never had a problem with it in a full year of hard fishing.






Back to top
JAB528
LSU Fan
The Mexican Ocean
Member since Jun 2012
14781 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I used mine in saltwater, it crapped out in like 6 months. Now I'm sure the revo inshore is a totally different story, but that's a $250 reel. If I'm spending that on a reel I'm either getting another Calcutta or chronarch.






Back to top
jimbeaux82
LSU Fan
Natchitoches, La
Member since Oct 2008
1019 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I have fished all 3 and all are very good, but the Revo SX is the best there is for that price by a long shot. I fish mine in saltwater quite a bit without any problems





Back to top
  Replies (0)
DonChowder
LSU Fan
Caulifornea
Member since Dec 2012
4671 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I've used mine in both salt and fresh but always rinse them immediately after trip. I hope mine doesn't shite the bed cause I love the smooth casting and even smoother drag.

But I'm with you on the Calcutta. My two are both 18 years old and still function very well.



This post was edited on 5/2 at 11:37 am


Back to top
  Replies (0)
weisertiger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles, LA
Member since Sep 2007
1925 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Thanks coco, but I got a bunch of Academy gift cards I will be using to buy this reel, so I'm kinda stuck there.





Back to top
Langston
LSU Fan
Cenla
Member since Nov 2010
5988 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


quote:

I have used both the citica and S, I like them both for different things, citica is my cranking reel, s is better for worming IMO.


Im just the opposite. I like my citca for light applications and my revos for cranking and heavy jigs etc. Citica just feels too light for heavy cranking to me, but obviously it works if you use it.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
The Last Coco
LSU Fan
On the water
Member since Mar 2009
2857 posts
 Online 

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Hah. That's at least the third time this almost exact scenariory has played itself out on here. I've linked to great e-bay deals for hunting/fishing equipment only to have the OP let me know they have a gift certificate to Academy/BPS/Cabela's. I just find it amusing.

That being said, all of the reels are good and will do what you want them too. I have experience with both Shimano and Abu Garcia products, and for bass fishing and inshore fishing prefer the REVOs.

ETA: The drag on the REVOs is what really impresses me. Super smooth but can be set up to 20lbs+. If you're targeting bull reds, or even decide to venture out for mangroves, the added drag will come in handy.



This post was edited on 5/2 at 11:46 am


Back to top
  Replies (0)
DownshiftAndFloorIt
LSU Fan
The devil dreams on an idle horse
Member since Jan 2011
40074 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


Not revo s.

Mine lasted 6 months. It eats levelwind pawls






Back to top
AuburnCPA
Auburn Fan
Member since May 2008
17486 posts

re: Pick one - Shimano Citica vs. Revo S vs. Revo SX


I own multiple Revo SXs and they are my favorite reels of all time.





Back to top


Back to top