Posted byMessage
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

3rd to 1st now a balk?


I hear that correctly? Is it true for college as well?






Back to top
Share:
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
20083 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


I hope so. I have hated that move forever. I have never seen it work and played baseball through college.





Back to top
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


I'll just assume you mean you've hardly seen it work.





Back to top
lsu31always
USA Fan
Team 31™
Member since Jan 2008
97613 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


It is in MLB. No idea about college





Back to top
okietiger
USA Fan
Oklahoma City Area
Member since Oct 2005
23287 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


I picked a guy off at 3rd in Highschool with that move cuz he figured I was going to sleepwalk through it and immediately look to first no matter what.

His manager ripped his arse it was pretty funny. Picking a guy off at 3rd is pretty damn rare by the pitcher.

I'd argue it's more likely for the catcher to achieve it IMO.






Back to top
Spark2121
LSU Fan
Member since Mar 2009
195 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

I'll just assume you mean you've hardly seen it work.


This.

quote:

4LSU2


To say you have never seen it work probably means you didn't play through college like you say you did. Ill trust that you are telling the truth about that so you have to have seen it as some point work.



This post was edited on 1/15 at 9:32 am


Back to top
Choupique19
LSU Fan
The cheap seats
Member since Sep 2005
29438 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

hope so. I have hated that move forever. I have never seen it work and played baseball through college.


You've never seen it work because pitchers are "too cool" to put good effort into it. A good first to third move can accomplish two things. One, if good enough it might steal an out. But most commonly, a good first to third move can create hesitation in the base runner. If you've ever seen a runner caught stealing in a first and thrid situation, perhaps the runner from first got a late break because he was making sure that the pitcher went home.

I've seen a good 3rd to 1st move be successful many times. It's just that my view of successful may be different than yours.






Back to top
LSUBoo
Bowling Green Fan
My Posting Goes To 11.
Member since Mar 2006
57764 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

3rd to 1st now a balk?
I hear that correctly? Is it true for college as well?


It's an MLB rule change, and I think it still has to be approved by the Player's Union.






Back to top
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


Is that vote a formality?





Back to top
LSUBoo
Bowling Green Fan
My Posting Goes To 11.
Member since Mar 2006
57764 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

Is that vote a formality?


The article I read made it sound like it.






Back to top
Rouge
USA Fan
Member since Oct 2004
93096 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


i dont think you can make this rule chance without also outlawing an inside move to 2b without a throw





Back to top
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


So I guess college will be a year behind.





Back to top
bddwolfpack
Rutgers Fan
NYC
Member since Sep 2010
9407 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


Bud Selig





Back to top
okietiger
USA Fan
Oklahoma City Area
Member since Oct 2005
23287 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

i dont think you can make this rule chance without also outlawing an inside move to 2b without a throw


Which is highly ineffective as well






Back to top
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


What did he do wrong now in your eyes?





Back to top
bddwolfpack
Rutgers Fan
NYC
Member since Sep 2010
9407 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


He's a spineless boob.

People bitch and moan about the third to first move for no reason, so he allows for it to be outlawed.

There's no reason for this.






Back to top
bbap
Indiana Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2006
77208 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


Disagree. Glad it's gone.





Back to top
reddman
Miami (OH) Fan
NOLA
Member since Jul 2005
67733 posts
 Online 

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


The game is slow enough as it is. I have no problem with this rule.





Back to top
bddwolfpack
Rutgers Fan
NYC
Member since Sep 2010
9407 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


This move happens maybe twice a night throughout baseball and adds literally 30 seconds to the game.

I'm against change in baseball for the most part, a purist.






Back to top
Choupique19
LSU Fan
The cheap seats
Member since Sep 2005
29438 posts

re: 3rd to 1st now a balk?


quote:

i dont think you can make this rule chance without also outlawing an inside move to 2b without a throw




Which is highly ineffective as well


Not if a pitcher puts good effort into creating a good move

6:10 mark






Back to top



Back to top