Is Eli Manning ahead of Brees now???

ETA: Also 7 pages.

quote:

---

The Giants D helped them to those 2 Superbowls.

---

This, Brees with the Giants D would be unstoppable.

quote:

---

Try to be Unbiased.........

---

only morons are the intellectually lazy would say Eli is over Brees.

If Gronk catches that hail mary, you wouldn;t even ask, that should tell its a stupid question.

here's my biased answer: no
here's my unbiased answer: no
here's my answer if eli wins another ring and drew doesn't: no

super bowl rings is a measure of a quarterback's greatness, but it's not the only one.

you are pretty dang freaky

quote:

---

I'd rank them right now, as in ability as of now:

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Drew Brees
3. Tom Brady
4. Eli Manning
5. Peyton Manning

---

So if you had to pick either Eli or Peyton for one season, assuming Peyton is healthy, you'd pick Eli? Well ok...

You damn straight. Peyton Manning is a amazing regular season QB. When the playoffs roll around, he chokes it up. I can't tell you how many years he cost his team in the game in the playoffs. Hell, his sole SB ring, he choked those playoffs up. I remember him throwing constant INTs costing his team big in clutch situations. That was one reason the Patriots were such a huge rival to them, Peyton always looked horrible in the playoffs. Hell, the AFC Championship game Peyton threw like 3 picks in that game when they won the SB. His defense came up with a miracle play towards the end that elevated them to success. Then SB was history because they were playing a vastly inferior opponent.

Clutch situation against NO and he threw the game winning TD against the Saints.

Got knocked out of the playoffs multiple years by boneheaded TOs from HIM.

Would I rather Eli on my team over Peyton? Yes. And the SB rings prove it because when it matters, Eli makes the plays.

Yea, the more rings logic is bad.

But it is a perfect explanation when the QB makes plenty of clutch plays to get them those rings.

Eli's throw last night and the previous SB basically were the two plays of each game...

Those plays basically set them up for a win. Clutch man, clutch. All about being clutch in the playoffs.

Does Drew have a shitty defense? Yes. Was Drew still throwing out his mind to put his team in position to win games in the playoffs? Yes. Was Peyton pressing too hard and costing his team in key situations? Yes.

And no I didn't say Big Ben or Eli is better than Brees. Get some fricking reading comprehension skills. Eli is definitely elite with the top 4 though.