Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Unbiased Bama Fan
Member since Dec 2011
2950 posts

Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Both QBs were in the same draft class and are usually ranked very close to each other in all-time QB rankings. Who do you have ranked higher on your all-time QB list?

Case for Marino

Was clearly the far more prolific and superior passing QB (Destroys Elway in TD/INT ratio and has the edge in Comp%, TD%, INT%, YPA, QB rating and pretty much every other passing stat you can think of)

Was 2-1 against Elway and badly outplayed him in head to head meetings (Marino against Broncos: 74-
118, 62.7 Comp%, 888 yards, 7 TDs, 3 INTs, 7.5 YPA, 94.88 QB rating, Elway against Dolphins: 45-96, 46.9 Comp%, 583 yards, 1 TDs, 3 INTs, 6.1 YPA, 56.9 QB rating)

Never had a rushing attack ranked higher than 13th in his career at a time when a good running game was essential to winning the Super Bowl

Had a top 10 defense only five times in his career, by contrast Elway had a defense that ranked in the top 10 in points allowed per game nine times



Case for Elway

Led his team to three Super Bowls in the '80s compared to only one for Marino despite having a very limited supporting cast

Had far inferior talent at WR compared to Marino until the tail end of his career (Nobody will ever mistake Vance Johnson and Mark Jackson for the Marks brothers)

Was a better playoff QB and clutch performer than Marino (Had a better QB rating and averaged over a yard more per pass attempt in the playoffs and had numerous signature moments in the clutch that Marino just doesn't have)

Was a better running QB than Marino and opposing teams had to account for his ability to beat them with his arm or his legs







Back to top
Share:
ThugginItandLovinIt
LSU Fan
Member since Aug 2011
840 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Elway. Marino has no SB. Ergo, Elway. Laces out.





Back to top
Kafka
New Orleans Saints Fan
Remembering The Alamo
Member since Jul 2007
70933 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Marino was the best passer I ever so but overall I would have to take Elway -- he was the Peyton of his day





Back to top
BayouBengals03
Michigan State Fan
lsu14always
Member since Nov 2007
56333 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Really close. Both are in my top 5 of all-time.





Back to top
TigerintheNO
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jan 2004
22514 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

Was a better playoff QB and clutch performer than Marino


Elway had some of the worst SuperBowl performamces






Back to top
BayouBengals03
Michigan State Fan
lsu14always
Member since Nov 2007
56333 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


True, but he pretty much led them to the Super Bowl in each of those years, where they faced a far superior opponent each time.





Back to top
Unbiased Bama Fan
Member since Dec 2011
2950 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

Elway had some of the worst SuperBowl performamces


In the playoffs, Elway had a better QB rating, averaged over a yard more per pass attempt and rushed for 400 more yards than Marino. He also had a 14-8 record in the playoffs while Marino was only 8-10 in the playoffs. It's hard to make an argument for Marino being a better postseason QB than Elway.



This post was edited on 12/26 at 7:46 pm


Back to top
PuntBamaPunt
Vanderbilt Fan
Member since Nov 2010
6278 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


The drive.





Back to top
theunknownknight
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2005
26848 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Marino easy.

Elway is overrated.






Back to top
SPEEDY
Lamar Fan
2005 Tiger Smack Poster of the Year
Member since Dec 2003
59174 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

In the playoffs, Elway had a better QB rating, averaged over a yard more per pass attempt and rushed for 400 more yards than Marino. He also had a 14-8 record in the playoffs while Marino was only 8-10 in the playoffs. It's hard to make an argument for Marino being a better postseason QB than Elway



What does any of that, have to do with:


quote:

Elway had some of the worst SuperBowl performamces






Back to top
COTiger
LSU Fan
Colorado
Member since Dec 2007
9929 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


He got there. How many times did Marino get there?





Back to top
Unbiased Bama Fan
Member since Dec 2011
2950 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


My point is that Elway was better in the playoffs regardless of his Super Bowl performances. It shouldn't be a factor in determining the better postseason QB because Marino only played in one SB and his performance in that game was mediocre.





Back to top
BayouBengals03
Michigan State Fan
lsu14always
Member since Nov 2007
56333 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


He's saying that performance in the Super Bowl isn't everything. There are a lot of other games.






Back to top
BoardReader
Arkansas Fan
Arkansas
Member since Dec 2007
2216 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

What does any of that, have to do with: quote: Elway had some of the worst SuperBowl performamces




Given that Super Bowls are part of the playoffs, it illustrates that even given 3 bad Super Bowls, he managed to overcome these tremendous shitstains of performance to put up extremely respectable numbers.






Back to top
ohiovol
Tennessee Fan
Member since Jan 2010
14534 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Not to mention Elway also won 2 Super Bowls and was the Super Bowl MVP in the second.





Back to top
ZTiger87
LSU Fan
Member since Nov 2009
11437 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

True, but he pretty much led them to the Super Bowl in each of those years, where they faced a far superior opponent each time.


The Fk? Terrell Davis was the best player on the Broncos in their 2 super bowl wins. He ran for over 100 yards in every playoff game both years. Against GB he had 150 yards rushing and 3 tds. Elway had 127 yards passing, an int and a rushing td in that game. Also, the Falcons were not a superior opponent in their 2nd superbowl.






Back to top
Tactical1
New Orleans Saints Fan
Denham Springs
Member since May 2010
14454 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Elway and I don't think it's close.





Back to top
Marciano1
LSU Fan
Marksville, LA
Member since Jun 2009
8360 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Marino





Back to top
Vicks Kennel Club
USA Fan
Fire Jurgen
Member since Dec 2010
18558 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


Dan Marino.





Back to top
Vicks Kennel Club
USA Fan
Fire Jurgen
Member since Dec 2010
18558 posts

re: Who was the better QB: Dan Marino or John Elway?


quote:

Who was the better QB


quote:

Was clearly the far more prolific and superior passing QB (Destroys Elway in TD/INT ratio and has the edge in Comp%, TD%, INT%, YPA, QB rating and pretty much every other passing stat you can think of)


I think you answered your own question.






Back to top


Back to top




//