cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
nevilletiger79
LSU Fan
Monroe
Member since Jan 2009
14641 posts

cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil



preferances?






Back to top
Share:
LSUEnvy
LSU Fan
LakeClusterChuck
Member since May 2011
7535 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


p-nut for frying my turkeys, great taste





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Walt OReilly
Arizona State Fan
Cubs Fan
Member since Oct 2005
82439 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


quote:

peanut oil






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Filthy Mitten
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2011
217 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


People who insist on peanut don't know what they're talking about. Cottonseed has a comparable smoke point and won't burn up like cheaper oils. you also can't go wrong with Canola. Both are cheaper than Peanut. If you're cooking 1 turkey go with cheap clear fry.





Back to top
Kajungee
LSU Fan
South ,Section 6 Row N
Member since Mar 2004
15658 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


If you're cooking 1 turkey use Lard





Back to top
dpd901
LSU Fan
Thibodaux
Member since Apr 2011
2271 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


From a technical standpoint, similar smoke points, but peanut oil has a lower iodine value (chemical test that measures "stability" of the oil). The lower the IV, the longer the oil should last at temperature.

If you are frying one turkey, and have a thermometer, you definitely don't need Peanut Oil or Cottonseed Oil. The cheapest vegetable oil you can find will work fine as long as you keep your temperature 350F or below, and I'd challenge any one to take the Pepsi Challenge and tell me which one was fried in peanut vs. soybean or canola (vegetable) oil.

Lard would make a difference in flavor for sure as would beef tallow.

Cottonseed Oil's main distinguishing characteristic is that it gives you a consistent golden brown color throughout it's fry life. When using other oils fresh... your first batches are too light, and get too dark after multiple batches. Cottonseed oil solves that problem, which is why Cafe Du Monde swears by it for thier bengiets. Great for fish, fries, etc... when you start with fresh oil.






Back to top
Filthy Mitten
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2011
217 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


Cottonseed is a favorite of every beignet shop in LA. Specifically Lou-Ana brand.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
LSUEnvy
LSU Fan
LakeClusterChuck
Member since May 2011
7535 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


quote:

If you're cooking 1 turkey go with cheap clear fry.


I'm cooking 3 and price isn't relevant, anyway p-nut oil tastes much better






Back to top
TIGER2
LSU Fan
Mandeville.La
Member since Jan 2006
8724 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


Cottonseed oil is very good oil. It has a unique smell. next time you open up a fresh jug,give it a smell. Smells like cake! And no,it does not add any flavor to food.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
dpd901
LSU Fan
Thibodaux
Member since Apr 2011
2271 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


quote:

anyway p-nut oil tastes much better



If I fried 10 turkeys in Peanut Oil, Canola Oil, Soybean Oil, Corn Oil, Sunflower Oil... There is no way you'd be able to pick out the peanut oil in a blind test. It can't be done. I work for the largest producer of frying oil in the world, and have been selling food oils for about 15 years.

Lard and Tallow are a different story, but vegetable oils are so similar in taste profile, that flavor differences are completely negligible.



This post was edited on 11/17 at 8:24 pm


Back to top
RaginCajunz
LA-Lafayette Fan
Gonzales
Member since Mar 2009
1483 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


quote:

If I fried 10 turkeys in Peanut Oil, Canola Oil, Soybean Oil, Corn Oil, Sunflower Oil... There is no way you'd be able to pick out the peanut oil in a blind test. It can't be done. I work for the largest producer of frying oil in the world, and have been selling food oils for about 15 years.

Lard and Tallow are a different story, but vegetable oils are so similar in taste profile, that flavor differences are completely negligible.


Completely disagree, I'd take that challenge.






Back to top
dpd901
LSU Fan
Thibodaux
Member since Apr 2011
2271 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


You'd lose. I've done this test with many different food products with professional chefs, food scientists, culinary students, and other food service professionals multiple times.

In fact, we've had the research department at a major university perform a completely scientific study based on this very topic on behalf of a major restaurant chain that has used peanut oil exclusively for years. They just switched to a Canola product based on the results. The senior executives of that company couldn't tell the difference. Nor could any of the participants in the blind study. It's perception.

I'm not knocking peanut oil in anyway. It's a fantastic frying oil in every way. High smoke point, long lasting, etc...

I'm telling you that no one, can effectively single out product fried in peanut oil vs. other vegetable oils in a blind test on a consistent basis. The "nutty flavor" that it allegedly imparts on food is a myth.






Back to top
RaginCajunz
LA-Lafayette Fan
Gonzales
Member since Mar 2009
1483 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


I eat very little fried foods now. I know that food fried in peanut oil will "sit" ok with my stomach. Other oils will make me ill. I can guarantee I'll tell the difference from 1 the smell coming off the fryer and 2- the taste. This is particularly true with french fries, but holds true on other foods as well.





Back to top
dpd901
LSU Fan
Thibodaux
Member since Apr 2011
2271 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


Well, you'd be a total anomaly based on tons of scientific data. I'd give you 50/50 in a heads up vs. Soy bean oil, and 10% chance of guessing right in a multiple oil test. Everybody thinks they can do it blind going in. Nobody can.





Back to top
RaginCajunz
LA-Lafayette Fan
Gonzales
Member since Mar 2009
1483 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


I'm a regular gastronomical anomaly. If all oils are the same, why bother producing multiple types? Why not just produce the cheapest one that yields the largest profit margin?







Back to top
dpd901
LSU Fan
Thibodaux
Member since Apr 2011
2271 posts

re: cottonseed oil vs. peanut oil


There are differences. Peanut Oil is superior to just about any other commodity oil as a frying medium... It's more stable chemically so it lasts longer. Canola Oil is low in saturated fat. Soybean oil is cheap for those who want that. Cottonseed is pretty stable and has the color benefit that I discussed above. Corn, Sunflower, etc... all have their place.

There's also consumer demand. Peanut Oil really made it's bones a long time ago before thermostats were reliable. The higher smoke point performed really well in restaurants, and it's also very popular in the south where peanuts are grown. The flavor is mainly a perception thing. It's a great oil though.

We also do things with crop genetics, chemistry and blending that can make Soybean, Canola, Corn etc... perform like peanut oil or better.






Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top