Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
hawkster
Member since Aug 2010
5034 posts

Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun



(no message)






Back to top
Share:
coloradoBengal
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2007
32608 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


There's a lot of schools of thought on this.


Slugs are without a doubt the heaviest hitters, but you might have over penetration concerns.

#3 or #2 buck are the most common defense shells you'll find. But depending on your home situation, you might have overpenetration concerns with these as well.

Some people say you shouldn't use bird shot, but I tried an experiment at the range, and within room size distances... i.e. less than 20 - 25 feet, bird shot (#4) does a great job against soft targets. The pattern is so dense, its really devastating.

My recommendation is that if you live in the country and have no concerns about hitting your neighbors house, and your house is such that don't think you'll be sending rounds into your kid's bed... then slugs and buckshot combinations are the best. Whatever you feel most comfortable with.

If there are any concerns about over penetration, then load it up with some bird shot and learn to aim for the face and neck. You can put some buck shot in shell holder if it makes you feel better.




This post was edited on 9/30 at 8:57 pm


Back to top
TexasTiger
LSU Fan
Katy TX
Member since Sep 2003
4715 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


I like #4's. More pellets and they are moving quick coming out of the barrel.





Back to top
coloradoBengal
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2007
32608 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


I killed a feral pig with #4 birdshot. He was about 15 away. Dropped him cold. That's when I decided to do some tests and took some pumpkins to the range.

Most people dramatically over estimate the spread of their shotgun at short distances.






Back to top
Chris4x4gill2
Alabama Fan
North Alabama
Member since Nov 2008
2019 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


I use #2 Buckshot in my home defense 20ga





Back to top
  Replies (0)
hawkster
Member since Aug 2010
5034 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


Thanks to all. I'll try it out with some of these recommendations and come up with a plan.





Back to top
puffulufogous
USA Fan
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
5315 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


what birdshot does to 3 walls of drywall.

hickok45 shows the accuracy of 00 and 000 buck shot

birdshot at 15 feet

Just a couple things to think about regarding safety in a home defense situation. I can't tell you which has more energy/incapacitation potential between slug and buck in 20 gauge but from the looks of it accuracy is paramount (not that that is any surprise). You can always do buck or bird for the first couple and slugs after. When I only had a .410 I looked up similar information regarding stopping power and came to the conclusion that slugs were appropriate for me, but that was based on the fact that a .410 bore slug is the same diameter as a .45. 20 gauge on up may be different. good luck and be safe.






Back to top
halleburton
Member since Dec 2009
789 posts
 Online 

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


honestly it doesn't matter, but i would go no smaller than #4. DO NOT use slugs, buckshot are ideal...good spread and you'll devastate the intruder. Slug would too, but i'd rather a spread than one inaccurate glob of lead out of a shotgun.





Back to top
coloradoBengal
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2007
32608 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


quote:

honestly it doesn't matter, but i would go no smaller than #4. DO NOT use slugs, buckshot are ideal...good spread and you'll devastate the intruder. Slug would too, but i'd rather a spread than one inaccurate glob of lead out of a shotgun.


You're not getting a spread inside of 20ft in a house. Anything you hit with a 20ga slug and larger... a hand, a foot, a leg, arm or head... is getting blown clean off.

Now... slugs might also kill people two houses over... so, choose wisely based on your particular situation.






Back to top
halleburton
Member since Dec 2009
789 posts
 Online 

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


no chance a 20 ga slug goes through multiple walls and kills a neighbor. definitely 'possible' if you're shooting through an exterior wall only but the chances are negligible.

and you get at least get a spread of 10" or so at 30' so you don't need to be a good shot.

ive missed a couple deer at 50 yds with a slug, on a rest, deer not moving. wouldn't trust that to protect my family from a cracked up burglar.

just my opinion, i know i'll get 'em with buckshot if they break into my house.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
hawkster
Member since Aug 2010
5034 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


Very helpful post, thanks. Not too many interior situations where the distance would exceed 15 or 20 feet.





Back to top
Chris4x4gill2
Alabama Fan
North Alabama
Member since Nov 2008
2019 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


Check out theboxotruth.com Very good recomendations with real world research to back it up on self defense rounds.







Back to top
bayoudude
LSU Fan
Houma
Member since Dec 2007
17042 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun








Back to top
  Replies (0)
windriver
San Diego State Fan
West Monroe/San Diego
Member since Mar 2006
8656 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


Years ago, as in the early 70's I rarely thought of home defense.(I had a .270 and a 12 gauge in the gun rack of my truck)in the parking lot of Neville High School. Hunting was spontaneous so you kept your shite ready. I wasn't the only one.

It really never crossed my mind that I might have to shoot a human.

My how things have changed. Having gone off on a tangent I say #3Buck, slug, #3Buck, slug, #3 Buck. Of course you need to take the plug out.






Back to top
iwyLSUiwy
Southern Fan
I'm your huckleberry
Member since Apr 2008
21273 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


i pay chuck norris to sleep under my bed





Back to top
diat150
Tulane Fan
OPELOUSAS
Member since Jun 2005
19231 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


I saw a guy get shot in the stomach with 7.5 birdshot. he was incapacitated but didnt die.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
CaptainsWafer
Austin Peay Fan
Bone it like you own it.
Member since Feb 2006
40505 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


Shooting slugs defeats the purpose of having a shotgun in the first place.





Back to top
horsesandbulls
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Jun 2008
3568 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


quote:

Shooting slugs defeats the purpose of having a shotgun in the first place.


kinda my take on the whole thing






Back to top
  Replies (0)
hawkster
Member since Aug 2010
5034 posts

re: Best shells for 20 GA home defense pump gun


quote:

Check out theboxotruth.com Very good recomendations with real world research to back it up on self defense rounds.


Very good site. Looks like #3 buck may be the best choice. Good pattern, lethal penetrating power. My gun can handle 3", but I'm thinking 2.75" might have better spread at close ranges. Will test some rounds, but thanks for the help in narrowing down the choices.






Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top