Started By
Message

Why are deer bigger in some places rather than others

Posted on 1/19/16 at 10:36 pm
Posted by Masterag
'Round Dallas
Member since Sep 2014
18798 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 10:36 pm
Illinois, Wisconsin, Ohio, Texas hill country, etc. What's the deal? Fewer hunters per deer, magic water?
Posted by Dodd
Member since Oct 2003
21048 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 10:40 pm to
Body or rack?

Hill country deer are tiny and while plentiful, they rarely score >160s compared to big mid western and LA

Plants, terrain, soil affects both size of deer and horns.
Posted by Hammertime
Will trade dowsing rod for titties
Member since Jan 2012
43030 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 10:46 pm to
Food and genetics
Posted by dnm3305
Member since Feb 2009
13546 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:00 pm to
Distance from equator plays a big part in all animals, not just deer. Better nutrition from better soil can help too i would suppose.
Posted by rattlebucket
SELA
Member since Feb 2009
11420 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:01 pm to
Nutrients, genetics, weather. Deer in Bunkie dont need to weigh 300 lbs to make it through so called winter where it may touch the 20's a few times year whereas up north it is very cold and snow/true winter limits browse. Also just the sheer cold up north, the deer require additional insulation to survive.
Posted by wickowick
Head of Island
Member since Dec 2006
45793 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:04 pm to
Genetics and nutrition...
Posted by Duck Bucks and Zero
Member since Jan 2016
62 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:18 pm to
Of course genetics and nutrition but the biggest factor is distance from equator. A animal species will always be it's biggest and robust at it's farthest northern range from the equator. Its just science.
Posted by AubieALUMdvm
Member since Oct 2011
11713 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:18 pm to
Bergmanns rule

quote:

Bergmann's rule is an ecogeographic principle that states that within a broadly distributed taxonomic clade, populations and species of larger size are found in colder environments, and species of smaller size are found in warmer regions. Although originally formulated in terms of species within a genus, it has often been recast in terms of populations within a species. It is also often cast in terms of latitude.


Only the biggest and strongest survive to pass on their genes. Living in upstate NY I can assure you last year's winter put natural selection into play. No way any small or weak deer could have survived that one
This post was edited on 1/19/16 at 11:22 pm
Posted by ChatRabbit77
Baton Rouge
Member since May 2013
5857 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:21 pm to
Soil quality, amount of quality sustenance, and genetics.
Posted by Rize
Spring Texas
Member since Sep 2011
15751 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:33 pm to
Need to change Texas hill country to South Texas.
Posted by Masterag
'Round Dallas
Member since Sep 2014
18798 posts
Posted on 1/19/16 at 11:33 pm to
Interesting. Thanks for the input all.
Posted by Hammertime
Will trade dowsing rod for titties
Member since Jan 2012
43030 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 12:14 am to
That all goes out of the window once you start selectively breeding and feeding your animals
Posted by NWLA Tiguh12
Member since Jul 2015
2402 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 1:01 am to
quote:

Food and genetics
this 100%
Posted by CoachChappy
Member since May 2013
32505 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 6:11 am to
Our deer in the hill country are plentiful, and the racks look great, but they are not big deer. My FIL's big trophy this year didn't weigh over 150, but was a nice 10pt.
Posted by DownshiftAndFloorIt
Here
Member since Jan 2011
66763 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 6:51 am to
Deer in vastly different locations could practically be treated as entirely different species. Same goes for pretty much any species.
Posted by Rhino5
Atlanta
Member since Nov 2014
28897 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 6:52 am to
Colder weather produces larger animals. Insulation.
Posted by Tiger-Striped-Bass
The Bay Area
Member since Dec 2004
1266 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 7:30 am to
quote:

Biologists long ago identified eight distinct subspecies of whitetail deer in North America. In addition to the Coues deer and what I used to know as the Keys Deer (now generally referred to as the “Seminole deer”), there are six other subpopulations of whitetails--the differences between them are “size, appearance, habitats and adaptations in behavior by climactic condition,” according to Whitetail Slam. Under this new system, hunters pursuing a deer slam can notch credit for tagging bucks in each of these distinct regions, which as the map illustrates, is a pretty large swath of country.


quote:

WhitetailSLAM uses eight whitetailed deer territories to represent the traditional ranges of 8 hunt able North American whitetails included in the WhitetailSLAM award recognition platform. The whitetails in these eight territories have the most recognizable differences as to size, appearance, habitats and adaptation in behavior to climatic conditions. The map below outlines the 8 varied habitat areas that have allowed the whitetailed deer living in these areas to become strikingly different.


Field and Stream

Whitetail Slam

This post was edited on 1/20/16 at 7:36 am
Posted by Fratigerguy
Member since Jan 2014
4741 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 7:31 am to
Bergmann's rule, AND soil quality when speaking of antler size...glaciated soils. Follow the track of the ancient glaciers and you can find the richest soil. Richer soils equal better antler growing material.

Good example...greenbrier, one of the most abundant food sources for deer, varies in amount of protein over areas. Piney woods greenbrier in poor soil areas may provide 8-10% protein for deer. Greenbrier in Illinois, for example, may provide upwards of 20% protein. Same food, different results. A deer needs 16% average protein digestible intake for optimal antler growth. That's why just cutting and fertilizing natural browse is a great way to help your deer herd.
Posted by Pintail
Member since Nov 2011
10424 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 7:40 am to
quote:

Bergmanns rule


There was a good show on the outdoor channel a few weeks ago that went into detail about this. I didn't know about it until I saw the show. Really neat.
Posted by mack the knife
EBR
Member since Oct 2012
4183 posts
Posted on 1/20/16 at 7:54 am to
quote:

just cutting and fertilizing natural browse is a great way to help your deer herd.


+1
i started doing this a few years ago and have noticed better activity of quality deer at these locations vs corn feeders
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram