That show was pretty damn bad. At least Duck Dynasty kind of has a sitcom format to me. I've only watched a few episodes but it seems like it just tries to entertain without being ridiculous.
Duck Dynasty is a great show and even has a pretty good message about family that I like. Sure most of the things on there are staged but it's still great family entertainment, especially considering all the other garbage on TV right now. Thankfully we're starting baseball season soon and our TV time will be severely curtailed again.