Spinoff thread: Which Would You Rather Marry?

With all else being equal, if you had to choose, would you rather:
1. She insists on waiting before marriage, you're her first and only lover, she will garanteed never cheat on you or divorce you, but she almost never puts out after marriage (like once or twice a year on average).
2. Woman with a known sordid past, wants it all the time, but runs the risk of possibly cheating on you once married.

Which would you choose?