Probably. The line is increasingly diluting
Yep. Maybe the styles are changing, hormones in chicken or maybe it's because I'm just getting older. But teenage girls don't look like they use to. Years ago you could tell a big difference between a early and late teen girl. That's not the case any more.
Also, he said the guy look to be in his 30's. Unless the dude was about 13 when he fathered this girl, she is probably 14 at best, maybe younger.
Hate to break it to you OP, you were ogling a little girl.