Claw foot tub: Yay or Nay?

remodeling bathroom for a flip or rental(haven't decided)...have to hold min 1 year, so it will be a rental for at least ~6 months.

I have an empty box now(fully gutted), but it was never piped for a shower, and the tub drain is next to a window(can't put an in-wall shower there, without rigging it)




1. I can cheaply drywall/paint the whole bath and tile the floor. New Toilet, pedestal sink, and then put a new clawfoot tub in the place of the old tub(un-usable) with a drop 360 shower curtain, and an exposed shower pipe.

2. Put in a new shower/bath, but I'd have to move the drain of both the toilet and tub/shower to accommodate the new set-up.



Seems like the clawfoot would be the cheaper option without incurring all the plumber's butt$ and tile, but as a rental would I be better off putting in a new tiled shower with an efficient layout, as in less chance of people getting water all over the place.

What are the unknown issues with the claw foot tub, and are they just a cool idea but in real life a pain?

Property is old (70 years), so older styles can make sense.