Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message
locked post

Mel's likes and questionables...

Posted on 4/29/11 at 9:10 am
Posted by gismap
Member since Apr 2009
1841 posts
Posted on 4/29/11 at 9:10 am
ESPN Insider...so no link.

Three I liked

New Orleans Saints
The picks: Cameron Jordan (24), Mark Ingram (28)
Summary: New Orleans gave up some value by ceding a 2012 first-round pick to the Patriots, but nobody ends the first day with more overall talent in Round 1, and the value was great. Besides, given what they have on the current roster and what they were able to add on Thursday, nobody involved in the trade will expect that Round 1 pick to be a high one in 2012. Jordan is a tremendous value at No. 24. I thought he could go as high as No. 9 overall to Dallas, so you get a lot for the pick. This is a smart, versatile player who can get after the quarterback. Then the Saints got the No. 1 running back in the draft all the way down at No. 28. So they get two really good fits, plus the value, A great first day. (And the obvious tip of the cap to the Patriots, who continue to keep piling up picks.)

Arizona Cardinals
The picks: Patrick Peterson (5)
Summary: Arizona feels it can be a contender in 2011 if it has a quarterback. And the Cardinals knew that a rookie quarterback isn't the answer when you're talking about a team with playoff aspirations. So at No. 5 they took the best football player in the draft, and didn't get pulled into the run on quarterbacks. What does that mean? Well, clearly they can grab an arm later, but it also means they are going to look to the free-agent and trade markets for a quarterback. If you want to connect dots, remember that Philly really needs a cornerback, and has a quarterback the Cardinals might want to acquire in Kevin Kolb. Bottom line: In Peterson you have a gifted football player who makes you better immediately, and have made yourself an appealing destination for a quarterback who wants to move.

Detroit Lions
The picks: Nick Fairley (13)
Summary: Nobody benefited more from the run on quarterbacks than Detroit, who gets a player that could have landed among the top five picks all the way down at No. 13. I know the Lions need help in the secondary, but think about it this way: Nothing can help a secondary more than applying pressure on quarterbacks, and creating third-and-long situations. Then think about what the Lions have created up front with Ndamukong Suh and now Fairley. Both are disruptive, get after quarterbacks and play the run and the pass well. They can even be rotated. The line was getting good -- now it's a great strength.

Notables: I love the value the New York Jets got in grabbing Muhammed Wilkerson late. He fits the scheme perfectly. Robert Quinn is a great get for the St. Louis Rams. This is a player who has the talent to be in the mix as a No. 1 overall pick. He sat out a year and lost some ground, and St. Louis benefits. Peyton Manning has to be happy with the pick of Anthony Castonzo. That's a great get for the Colts. Impressed that the Redskins moved down. That's a franchise that needs picks, period. Baltimore had a deal fall through to move their pick, and dropped a spot, but still ended up with a big-time player at a position of need. That might be the ideal environment to give Smith the guidance he needs. Man, talk about a serious haul for a single pick. Mike Holmgren just gained a ton of leverage for Cleveland by stockpiling that many picks. Browns fans should be happy, despite how much they might have wanted a guy at No. 6.



Three question marks

Minnesota Vikings
The picks: Christian Ponder (12)
Summary: First of all, this is no shot at Ponder, who some personnel folks believe might be the most ready-to-play quarterback in this draft. But the Vikings looked like a team that panicked with this pick, given the context. They had no shot to trade down? Andy Dalton is still available going into the second day, and in taking Ponder, you also passed on Fairley and Quinn, a couple of guys who can help this team. Again, it's not called "Pick your favorite player." It's a draft. Order and the value of each pick are components that factor in. Should note: This doesn't mean the Vikings are done looking for solutions at quarterback. They could target one in a trade or via free agency.

Atlanta Falcons
The picks: Julio Jones (6)
Summary: The question here certainly isn't about the player. Jones is a gifted athlete, perhaps the second best in the whole draft, and Roddy White needs somebody on the other side of the formation to help take the heat off. But they gave up a lot in terms of picks. To think Cincy took a much-needed wide receiver just two picks before them and gave up nothing, and you've given away a pair of first-round picks and three others, and it adds a little perspective. I doubt they'll regret having Jones around, but it's hard to get those picks back.

Seattle Seahawks
The picks: James Carpenter (25)
Summary: Credit the conviction of the Seahawks' front office. This team started 10 different offensive line combinations last year and it really set its offense back. The Seahawks are clearly determined to add talent and build continuity. But Carpenter is a guy they could have gotten later, in my opinion. Gabe Carimi and Derek Sherrod are still on the board, and either could shift to the right side.

Notables: We knew Tennessee liked Jake Locker. And while I don't think they could have gotten him if they traded down past No. 12, he's not ready to start, and they still have a void at quarterback. A little surprised that Cleveland gets so much value in trading down, then makes a move up only to get Phil Taylor. While Taylor is the best true anchor tackle in the draft, he could have been around for them later. Kansas City then reaches a bit themselves on Baldwin, a second-round talent in my book. Mike Pouncey will be a fine player, but isn't a remarkable value at No. 15 (even though I'd pegged him there in the mock).

Posted by BlacknGold
He Hate Me
Member since Mar 2009
12029 posts
Posted on 4/29/11 at 9:19 am to
good read. yeah id say along with atlanta sucking dick to get julio, the vikings lost out on the concept of the draft.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram