Megan is Missing seems like it has kind of a Poughkeepsie Tapes feel to it. The Bay I feel like I could be disappointed in, but it looks interesting enough. And Loved Ones, I saw the trailer for that one a while back but forgot about it. I'm glad I saw it again in this thread.
Haev you ever seen The Poughkeepsie Tapes? It's pretty fricked up. It's pretty good though, and definitely pretty realistic.
I googled Megan is Missing and some of the pics that came up reminded me of TPT. You used to be able to watch it on youtube, but not sure if that's still there.