Benjamin said The Guy from Mad Men would be great but you cant do archer without his voice imo
Jon Hamm would be a great Archer. He's actually hysterical, though you wouldn't know it from Mad Men. He hosted or guest starred on SNL and blew it up.
Aisha Tyler SHOULD play Lana. She IS Lana. And I don't mean she plays Lana on the show, I think she embodies the character or could, at the very least, pull it off quite well.
Chris Parnell should play Cyril. He plays the bumbling oaf oddball well.
I don't really like the idea of John C. Reilly or Will Ferrell playing Krieger. Both are too over the top. I would actually prefer to see Rudd or somebody with a little more subtlety play Krieger.
Barry should be played by Chris Pine or Ryan Reynolds, who are basically interchangeable.
Pam would be perfectly played by Melissa McCarthy.
Carol/Cheryl should be played by Kristen Wiig, Judy Greer, or someone similar.
Malory should be Jessica Walter.
Ray should be Sam Rockwell or something.