I was actually thinking about John Lithgow vs Elliot Gould. I think I have to go Lithgow.
Interesting note, Mike's (Paul Rudd) mom on Friends is Ted's mom on HIMYM.
Kathleen Turner as Chandlers dad might actually beat Dauber as Marshall's dad. But Ray Wise as Robin's dad is probably my favorite.
ETA: And on the subject of crazy guest star stalker chick: Brooke Sheilds > Britney Spears.
This post was edited on 3/18 at 12:51 pm