like chuck weis, right?
Are you really comparing the two?
yes. everyone said that all chuck weis had to do was show up with his fistful of jewelry and it would seal the deal. it worked at first, but eventually his coaching acumen proved ineffective in college.
ultimately i feel BB would suffer the same fate. i think he'd be more like his pre-brady days as he wouldnt have a HOF QB to mask his mistakes. im a huge BB fan and i think its a unanimous top 2 coach in the league if hes not the top spot. but hes got serious flaws-- anyone notice he cant draft a college WR? hes about 0 for 25 in the category. hes a defensive mastermind, yet hasnt fielded a decent defense since he had tons of old veteran players (tedy bruschi, vrabel, harrison) back in 07. in college you dont get to play 12 year vets. you'd think he could coacch up these young guys hes drafted, but theyre still a work in progress
belichick is the perfect NFL coach but wouldnt be nearly as successful in college.