Agree with your top 5, but not the order.
5. Big Ben
The Big Ben at 5 is debatable. But 2 SB rings, and clutch play in the 4th Q (yes despite the stinkers late this season) give him the edge IMO.
If not Ben at 5, I would say Eli.
Falcons fans saying Ryan should be in there are plain stupid. Ryan just won his FIRST playoff game ever in which his team coughed up a 20-0 HALFTIME lead, and survived on a last second FG.
Ryan has NO Super Bowl wins. Hes top 10, and right now I'd say he'd be 7th at best after Eli. But hes not top 5. No way right now.