LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages - Tiger Rant - LSU Sports Forum

Posted by	Message
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:54 p.m.) Positions: 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- 4.Olines adv.- 5.Dline adv.- 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - 9. Miles V. Saban Adv.- 10. Special Teams Adv.- eta: My take: 1.LSU 2.Bama 3.LSU 4.Bama 5.Bama 6.Bama 7.LSU 8.LSU 9.?? 10.LSU This post was edited on 11/3 at 6:16 p.m.
Back to top
pistolpete23 LSU Fan FUSC Member since Dec 2007 400 posts Online	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:56 p.m. to Sammobile) quote: My take: 1.LSU 2.Bama 3.LSU 4.Bama 5.Bama 6.Bama 7.LSU 8.LSU +1
Back to top
rocket32484 LSU Fan NOLA Member since Jan 2008 754 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:57 p.m. to Sammobile) quote: 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- LSU 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- BAMA 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- LSU 4.Olines adv.- BAMA 5.Dline adv.- BAMA 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- BAMA 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- LSU 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - LSU
Back to top
guttata LSU Fan prairieville Member since Feb 2006 9912 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:05 p.m. to rocket32484) Sounds about right. I guess it will come down to coaching.
Back to top
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:24 p.m. to guttata) quote: Sounds about right. I guess it will come down to coaching. relax we have one of the best coaches in college football
Back to top
lsugradman LSU Fan Houston,TX Member since Sep 2003 4427 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:28 p.m. to Sammobile) Yano?
Back to top
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:12 p.m. to lsugradman) quote: Yano? Coach Miles in one of the best in the Nation today
Back to top
jfortenberrylsu LSU Fan On the outskirts Member since Oct 2007 1915 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:18 p.m. to Sammobile) quote: 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline quote: 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- Ingram and Richardson quote: 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- LSU by a good bit quote: 4.Olines adv.- 5.Dline adv.- Bama on both quote: 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- Toss up imho quote: 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - Domination quote: 9. Miles V. Saban Adv.- I thnk Miles more often rises to the occasion, Saban is more consistant. eeehhhh. Saban i guess
Back to top
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:21 p.m. to jfortenberrylsu) quote: I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline quote: Ingram and Richardson just the players on their own merit
Back to top
Geaux9 LSU Fan Covington LA Member since Apr 2009 956 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:43 p.m. to jfortenberrylsu) quote: I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline Its just the players, not how they perform with the offense around them
Back to top
Chimlim LSU Fan Baton Rouge, LA Member since Jul 2005 5133 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 4:36 p.m. to Sammobile) 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- LSU 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- Bama 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- LSU 4.Olines adv.- Bama 5.Dline adv.- Bama 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- Bama, but its close. LSU LBs have been the strength of the defense this year. 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- LSU 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - LSU 9. Miles V. Saban Adv.- Bama Unfortunatley, Bama has the Dline and Oline advantage. This might be a huge factor.
Back to top
LC412000 LSU Fan Any location where a plane flies Member since Mar 2004 1802 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 4:53 p.m. to Sammobile) quote: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages Positions: 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- Even 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- Bama 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- LSU 4.Olines adv.- Bama 5.Dline adv.- Bama 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- LSU 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- LSU 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - LSU 9. Miles V. Saban Adv.- Bama LSU-4 Bama-4 Even-1 Based upon my rankings, the QB play will determine the winner of the game
Back to top
Tigerwaffe LSU Fan Member since Sep 2007 816 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 5:05 p.m. to LC412000) I say Miles v. Saban is a wash: Les' clock management v. Saban's conservatism. It'll be interesting to see if either coach does any out-of-the-box planning for this game; I'd give Les the nod here.
Back to top
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:07 p.m. to Tigerwaffe) quote: I say Miles v. Saban is a wash: :interesting:
Back to top
Keys Open Doors LSU Fan Ski Slopes in van Nuys Member since Dec 2008 8918 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:10 p.m. to Sammobile) I think that every category is close except for RB, WR, OL, and DL. Bama is noticeably better in three of these positions, while LSU is clearly better at receiver. I think that LSU's secondary is better than Bama's, while Bama's linebackers are better, but the units for both teams are quite good. I also think Jefferson is a better quarterback than McElroy, but neither of them really impress me. Both teams also have good kickers and dangerous returners (Arenas and Trindon). It should be a close game.
Back to top
Leonides LSU Fan Baton Rouge Member since Aug 2009 434 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:11 p.m. to Keys Open Doors) What about special teams?
Back to top
ATLTiger Aight? Aight Member since Sep 2003 17978 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:14 p.m. to Sammobile) quote: 4.Olines adv.- 5.Dline adv.- both Bama, and therein lies the problem
Back to top
Sammobile Oregon Fan New Orleans, La Member since Jan 2009 7325 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:16 p.m. to Leonides) quote: What about special teams? edit
Back to top
AlexLSU LSU Fan Member since Jan 2005 17635 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:25 p.m. to Sammobile) 1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy QB adv.- Bama 2.Scott V. Ingram RB adv.- Bama 3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy WR adv.- LSU 4.Olines adv.- Bama 5.Dline adv.- Bama 6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders LB adv.- Bama, but close as frick 7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson CB adv.- LSU 8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall S adv. - LSU 9. Miles V. Saban Adv.- Bama 10. Special Teams Adv.- LSU
Back to top
AlexLSU LSU Fan Member since Jan 2005 17635 posts	re: LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages (Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:28 p.m. to LC412000) quote: Based upon my rankings, the QB play will determine the winner of the game The QB will rarely determine the game if one team has the clear advantage in the trenches on BOTH sides of the ball.
Back to top

Tiger Rant	Next Page »	Page 1 2 3
Return to Board

Advertising Info • Privacy Policy • Site Map • Contact Us
TigerDroppings.com is an independent website featuring LSU sports news & opinions. This website is neither affiliated with, nor endorsed by Louisiana State University or its athletic department. The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of TigerDroppings.com or its operators. ©Copyright. 2009 TigerDroppings.com
All Rights Reserved.