I would take Miles. But not in a landslide.
Honestly I wouldn't take anyone in a landslide over either one.
And I wouldn't take either one in a landslide over most coaches out there.
Most say Saban is the best out there, that could easily be true. But if you are going to tell me that Saban would no doubt have the same success here then I would say you are a fool. Because you can't possibly know.
I don't like Miles offense, and I, along with others didn't like Saban's offense either. But I can't realistically complain about our defense and special teams, or the recruiting under Miles.
Miles still has a success that I can't argue against. Things don't go your way all the time, all I can ask is that we are in the discussion.
I choose Miles. As frustrated as he might make me.
This post was edited on 1/5 at 3:15 am