1. Y.A. Tittle
2. Bert Jones
3. JaMarcus Russell
4. Rohan Davey
5. Miracle Mike Miley
6. Steve Ensminger/David Woodley
7. Mike Hillman
8. Warren Rabb.
9. Lynn Amedee
10. Nelson Stokely

This post was edited on 12/23/07 at 11:42 pm

Report Post

Posted by Louie T

htx

Member since Dec 2006

36300 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:43 pm to MiketheTiger69

How can you not even have Hodson in your top 10?

Report Post

Posted by Eve of Destruction

Member since Nov 2004

1358 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:43 pm to oak

Hard to say. I always struggle with these things. How do you rate one great year (Davey) versus 4 very good years (Hodson)?

I'd say Jones, Tittle, Hodson, Russell, Davey

Report Post

Posted by A Mo Money

Baton Rouge

Member since Feb 2007

84 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:48 pm to Eve of Destruction

Matt Mauck has to be in the mix. 19-2 as a starter, 2 SEC Titles, and a National title. A Better career than most.

Report Post

Posted by tigerwoods

Hillman

Member since Jan 2007

3176 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:49 pm to Eve of Destruction

Worst = Jaime howard

Report Post

Posted by rbrava3

Baton Rouge

Member since Nov 2006

6821 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:50 pm to oak

Didn't Planchard get a few snaps in at QB? If he did then him.

Report Post

Posted by rbrava3

Baton Rouge

Member since Nov 2006

6821 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:50 pm to tigerwoods

quote:
Worst = Jaime howard

Condon is that you?

Report Post

Posted by Eve of Destruction

Member since Nov 2004

1358 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:50 pm to A Mo Money

I'm not fond of the "overall record and championships" statistic as a measure of quarterbacks. Those are team accomplishments. Case in point: Russell didn't win a championship, but Flynn has won the SEC and may win the national championship in his one year as starter. Is Flynn therefore better than Russell? I don't think so.

Report Post

Posted by MiketheTiger69

Moore/Norman, Oklahoma

Member since Jan 2004

3315 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:51 pm to Louie T

Because Hodson had a penchant for throwing a high ball. It was the skill of the receivers such as Wendell Davis that helped make him so good in the passing game, imo. I also don't think that he was that good of a runner to escape the rush where all of these other guys were more mobile.
I'd put Pat Screen in ahead of Hodson. The trouble with Screen and even Stokely was that they spent most of their careers injured but when they were healthy, they were as good as anybody.
I doubt you ever saw most of the guys on my list, so how can you question it?

Report Post

Posted by lsusportsman2

Member since Oct 2007

27232 posts

Posted on 12/23/07 at 11:52 pm to Santa Clause

josh booty. no JM is my vote.

Report Post

Posted by Fairhope Tiger

Member since Jan 2007

3615 posts

Posted on 12/24/07 at 12:06 am to lsusportsman2

Before Nelson Stokely was injured he was leading the nation in total offense.

Report Post

Posted by A Mo Money

Baton Rouge

Member since Feb 2007

84 posts

Posted on 12/24/07 at 12:52 am to Fairhope Tiger

quote:
Russell didn't win a championship, but Flynn has won the SEC and may win the national championship in his one year as starter. Is Flynn therefore better than Russell?

JaMarcus Russell will always be known as the most "physically gifted" QB that ever wore and LSU uniform. However, I would take a championship over hype every year! Isn't it ironic that we have a better offense this year after losing the #1 nfl draft pick at QB and 2 first round receivers?

Page 1 2 3 4