- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages
Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:54 pm
Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:54 pm
Positions:
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.-
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.-
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.-
4.Olines
adv.-
5.Dline
adv.-
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.-
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.-
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. -
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.-
10. Special Teams
Adv.-
eta:
My take:
1.LSU
2.Bama
3.LSU
4.Bama
5.Bama
6.Bama
7.LSU
8.LSU
9.??
10.LSU
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.-
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.-
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.-
4.Olines
adv.-
5.Dline
adv.-
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.-
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.-
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. -
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.-
10. Special Teams
Adv.-
eta:
My take:
1.LSU
2.Bama
3.LSU
4.Bama
5.Bama
6.Bama
7.LSU
8.LSU
9.??
10.LSU
This post was edited on 11/3/09 at 6:16 pm
12
Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:56 pm to Sammobile
quote:
My take:
1.LSU
2.Bama
3.LSU
4.Bama
5.Bama
6.Bama
7.LSU
8.LSU
+1
Posted on 11/3/09 at 1:57 pm to Sammobile
quote:LSU
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.- LSU
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- BAMA
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- BAMA
5.Dline
adv.- BAMA
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- BAMA
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. -
Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:05 pm to rocket32484
Sounds about right. I guess it will come down to coaching. 
Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:24 pm to guttata
quote:
Sounds about right. I guess it will come down to coaching.
relax we have one of the best coaches in college football
Posted on 11/3/09 at 2:28 pm to Sammobile
Yano?
Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:12 pm to lsugradman
quote:
Yano?
Coach Miles in one of the best in the Nation today
Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:18 pm to Sammobile
quote:
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.-
I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline
quote:
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.-
Ingram and Richardson
quote:
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.-
LSU by a good bit
quote:
4.Olines
adv.-
5.Dline
adv.-
Bama on both
quote:
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.-
Toss up imho
quote:
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.-
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. -
Domination
quote:
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.-
I thnk Miles more often rises to the occasion, Saban is more consistant. eeehhhh. Saban i guess
Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:21 pm to Chuck U Farley
quote:
I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline
quote:
Ingram and Richardson
just the players on their own merit
Posted on 11/3/09 at 3:43 pm to Chuck U Farley
quote:Its just the players, not how they perform with the offense around them
I say Mcelroy, because of running game and oline
Posted on 11/3/09 at 4:36 pm to Sammobile
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.- LSU
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- Bama
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- Bama
5.Dline
adv.- Bama
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- Bama, but its close. LSU LBs have been the strength of the defense this year.
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. - LSU
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.- Bama
Unfortunatley, Bama has the Dline and Oline advantage. This might be a huge factor.
QB adv.- LSU
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- Bama
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- Bama
5.Dline
adv.- Bama
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- Bama, but its close. LSU LBs have been the strength of the defense this year.
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. - LSU
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.- Bama
Unfortunatley, Bama has the Dline and Oline advantage. This might be a huge factor.
Posted on 11/3/09 at 4:53 pm to Sammobile
quote:
LSU vs. Alabama Advantages and Disadvantages
Positions:
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.- Even
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- Bama
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- Bama
5.Dline
adv.- Bama
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- LSU
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. - LSU
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.- Bama
LSU-4
Bama-4
Even-1
Based upon my rankings, the QB play will determine the winner of the game
Posted on 11/3/09 at 5:05 pm to LC412000
I say Miles v. Saban is a wash: Les' clock management v. Saban's conservatism. It'll be interesting to see if either coach does any out-of-the-box planning for this game; I'd give Les the nod here.
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:07 pm to Tigerwaffe
quote:
I say Miles v. Saban is a wash:
:interesting:
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:10 pm to Sammobile
I think that every category is close except for RB, WR, OL, and DL. Bama is noticeably better in three of these positions, while LSU is clearly better at receiver.
I think that LSU's secondary is better than Bama's, while Bama's linebackers are better, but the units for both teams are quite good. I also think Jefferson is a better quarterback than McElroy, but neither of them really impress me.
Both teams also have good kickers and dangerous returners (Arenas and Trindon). It should be a close game.
I think that LSU's secondary is better than Bama's, while Bama's linebackers are better, but the units for both teams are quite good. I also think Jefferson is a better quarterback than McElroy, but neither of them really impress me.
Both teams also have good kickers and dangerous returners (Arenas and Trindon). It should be a close game.
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:11 pm to Keys Open Doors
What about special teams?
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:14 pm to Sammobile
quote:
4.Olines
adv.-
5.Dline
adv.-
both Bama, and therein lies the problem
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:16 pm to Leonides
quote:
What about special teams?
edit
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:25 pm to Sammobile
1.Jefferson V. Mcelroy
QB adv.- Bama
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- Bama
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- Bama
5.Dline
adv.- Bama
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- Bama, but close as frick
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. - LSU
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.- Bama
10. Special Teams
Adv.- LSU
QB adv.- Bama
2.Scott V. Ingram
RB adv.- Bama
3.Lafell,TT,Randle V. JJ,Maze,McCoy
WR adv.- LSU
4.Olines
adv.- Bama
5.Dline
adv.- Bama
6. Riley,Colman,Sheppard V. Upshaw,McClain,Anders
LB adv.- Bama, but close as frick
7.Peterson,Hawkins V. Arenas,Jackson
CB adv.- LSU
8. Jones,Taylor V.Barron,Woodall
S adv. - LSU
9. Miles V. Saban
Adv.- Bama
10. Special Teams
Adv.- LSU
Posted on 11/3/09 at 6:28 pm to LC412000
quote:
Based upon my rankings, the QB play will determine the winner of the game
The QB will rarely determine the game if one team has the clear advantage in the trenches on BOTH sides of the ball.
Page 1 of 3
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News