If you haven't played the show, it may be ok. I tried it b/c pops only has a 360 and I was looking for a good baseball game for us to play online, but I ended up buying him a PS3 so we could play the show.
As far as baseball, eh, it gets the job done ok. It is not nearly as polished and way more clunky the the show.
I would definitely rent it first tho
This post was edited on 4/27 at 1:34 pm