Just no way man. I like both of those places, but comparing them to Clancy's is a no shot. And no Gautreau's on your list is kind of funny. It has been the most consistently great restaurant in New Orleans for 20 years.
My last meal is at the bar at Clancy's with Garth serving me.
Shrimp remoulade, best version in town and history for that matter.
Smoked softshell crab
Peppermint ice cream, or banana if they have it
Lemon icebox pie
Multiple bottles of whatever Cabernet Garth suggests.
Coroners Office. Close the coffin.
They have the best wine list in town for the value, perhaps the country. It is a truly great place. Plus, I'll know like 3/4 of the people there.