See right now (I know McGahee hasn't played tonight) they are separated by 14 yards. BJE has 1 more fumble and 1 less TD which can account for the difference in 14 fantasy points. Tonight the gap could widen I know but I see them as fairly even going forward as BJE has a more favorable schedule going forward and McGahee has Hillman who could work into his carries. I do think McGahee has a better chance to get that 100 yards and have those 20+ games though.
So guess that is why I have it closer than you do,
Roberts also has almost 70 fantasy points which is almost as many as McGahee has.
This post was edited on 10/15 at 2:11 pm