Oh I am not questioning his production when he is on the field. I just don't trust him to stay healthy for a full season. He is not nearly as bad as say Ahmad Bradshaw in regards to health concerns but still he has enough injury history to turn me away.
Plus in this particular situation I would take Cruz because I find his offense much more attractive for fantasy purposes. The bottom line is I just don't think that Houston's run first offense is very conducive for Andre's potential to have a monster game like the one that Cruz had 2 weeks ago. Yes, if Johnson remains healthy then he will most likely have slightly more receptions and yards than Cruz but not as many TDs but again that is a big if for me.