I think the asterisk is probably for the "Ellis T. Jones" award. It goes to the player who scores the most points for himself. You aren't eligible as a program to win the Fulmer Cup until you have 2 different players involved, so Utah probably isn't eligible to win the whole thing yet.
In order to be eligible to win the Fulmer Cup, a school must have more than one player charged (a school may not win the cup on the basis of a single player's criminal record; this is known as the Ellis T. Jones III Rule, named after the San Jose State wide receiver who in 2006 accumulated 31 points by himself having been charged with 13 felony counts, including robbery, assault, and kidnapping). However, the Ellis T. Jones III Award for Individual Achievement is given to the player with the single highest point total.