Should Umpires be Suspended? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
tduecen
Tulane Fan
The internet
Member since Nov 2006
101107 posts
 Online 

Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

John Hirschbeck was among them this afternoon, when he went looking for a confrontation and found it in Nationals outfielder Bryce Harper.

Harper check-swung on a 2-2 slider from Pirates starter Wandy Rodriguez, which just barely escaped the edge of the strike zone. Home plate umpire Bob Davidson appealed to third base umpire Hirschbeck, who ruled that Harper had swung at the offering. Harper, exasperated, expressed his disagreement with the call some 100 feet away. Hirschbeck immediately threw up his hands and yelled at Harper, like a drunk guy looking for trouble in a bar. He walked towards home plate, continuing to gesticulate and shout as Harper quietly talked to Davidson from the batter’s box. Third base coach Trent Jewett intercepted Hirschbeck as he stomped towards Harper, but it was no matter as Hirschbeck ejected Harper from the game shortly thereafter.


I know Braves fans would find this acceptable but what about everyone else? Video Is Here of Incident







Back to top
Share:
Choupique19
LSU Fan
The cheap seats
Member since Sep 2005
29469 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Yes, umpires should be suspended. If a coach made a mistake as egregious as some of the umpire's calls, they would be fired. See Grady Little leaving Pedro Martinez in the game one bloop single too long.





Back to top
dhuck20
Georgia Fan
Macon, GA (The good side)
Member since Oct 2012
1734 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Umpires running rampant with no Bobby Cox's in baseball dugouts. Gonzalez would probably walk out there and shake his hand.





Back to top
GM19
Alabama Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2010
795 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


The Ryan Howard ejection that they linked in the video was even worse. Some of those guys obviously are on a power trip





Back to top
oOoLsUtIgErSoOo
LSU Fan
Louisiana
Member since Aug 2006
16131 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


If I were that coach and the ump would have tossed my best player for that I think I'd have launched every base in the infield into the stands on my way out the park.





Back to top
medtiger
LSU Fan
Cubs Fan
Member since Sep 2003
17043 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Yea, Hirschbeck needs to be disciplined. Umpires need to show restraint. It's a little different when a player or coach is screaming in their face, but Harper didn't even walk towards him. Hirschbeck should've made his call, let Harper voice his displeasure, and let the game continue. Unfortunately, some of these a-holes think people are paying to watch them umpire.





Back to top
oOoLsUtIgErSoOo
LSU Fan
Louisiana
Member since Aug 2006
16131 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Look at the two names of the players that got ejected. That probably has more to do with it than anything. If Johnny Unknown had done what Bryce Harper or Howard did the ump would have probably laughed.





Back to top
dhuck20
Georgia Fan
Macon, GA (The good side)
Member since Oct 2012
1734 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


How about shoo'ing batters away?

Obviously too close to take, but Holbrook shoos BJ away for contesting the call.






Back to top
Roughneck
Texas Fan
Member since Feb 2005
8052 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Reasons like this is why we're eventually heading to an automated/non-human umpire system.





Back to top
lsu31always
USA Fan
Team 31™
Member since Jan 2008
97688 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:


I know Braves fans would find this acceptable

From the ATL Thread today.
quote:

#umpshow

quote:

frick that umpire

quote:

People paid to see Bryce Harper play. No one paid to see that guy umpire, and he was looking to throw out Harper. I hope Davey got ejected too






Back to top
beaver
USA Fan
The 755 Club
Member since Sep 2009
35012 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


wtf are those announcers talking about saying "these umpires have no business putting their hands on howard"

he was never even close to touched






Back to top
medtiger
LSU Fan
Cubs Fan
Member since Sep 2003
17043 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

How about shoo'ing batters away? Obviously too close to take, but Holbrook shoos BJ away for contesting the call.


I've got no problem with that one. The ump gave him more leeway than usual for balls/strikes. He even told him to go back to the dugout again after Upton started yelling at him. Then, after the ejection, he didn't get up in Upton's face. He stood there and let Upton call him whatever 4 letter words he wanted.






Back to top
The White Lobster
Alabama Fan
Tuscaloosa
Member since Jul 2009
16264 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Amazing that Balkin Bob was behind the plate and it wasn't even him who threw a player out prematurely for arguing balls and strikes.





Back to top
medtiger
LSU Fan
Cubs Fan
Member since Sep 2003
17043 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

Reasons like this is why we're eventually heading to an automated/non-human umpire system.


No we aren't. There's plenty of technology out there that could allow for most calls to be made electronically in baseball. MLB doesn't even use replay to its full extent.






Back to top
The White Lobster
Alabama Fan
Tuscaloosa
Member since Jul 2009
16264 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Yeah if I remember correctly it was correctly called too. Holbrook shouldn't have shooed him off but that was no excuse for BJ to get himself ejected.

Of course I can't blame him because Holbrook called the infield fly, and the strike zone was pretty bad that game.






Back to top
DeboseKnows
Florida Fan
Gainesville
Member since Dec 2012
664 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

The Ryan Howard ejection that they linked in the video was even worse. Some of those guys obviously are on a power trip

I just saw that for the first time, that pissed me off

The way he called him out then ejected him, guys a prick.






Back to top
dhuck20
Georgia Fan
Macon, GA (The good side)
Member since Oct 2012
1734 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


Umpires think they are the game nowadays


This post was edited on 5/5 at 8:43 pm


Back to top
Tiger n Miami AU83
Auburn Fan
Miami
Member since Oct 2007
31896 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

Yes, umpires should be suspended.






Back to top
jacks40
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2007
10676 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

Should Umpires be Suspended?


Umps and NBA refs need to be suspended publicly much more often than they are for this "look at me" behavior they exhibit so often.

For bad calls I think suspension could be warranted if consistent and egregious but should be done privately by leagues.






Back to top
goldenbadger08
LSU Fan
In TH03's Head
Member since Oct 2011
21657 posts

re: Should Umpires be Suspended?


quote:

guys a prick.
quote:

Yes, umpires should be suspended.
damn






Back to top



Back to top