Shut him down??? He scored over 30 points a game in EVERY SINGLE GAME of the NBA Finals and was the MVP. How many other players in history have done that?
He shot under 42% against him! 42% A center! Shooting under 42%. When you are a center guarded by another center and shoot 42% while your opponent shoots over 56% on you, it doesn't matter how many points you score. You got your arse owned.
As for your question, Jordan did it in 93. Averaged 41 ppg on 51% shooting. A guard had a higher shooting percentage than a Center. Tsk tsk tsk.
Speaking of Shaq, he averaged 38 ppg on 61% shooting in the 2000 Finals. Also scored over 35 in each of the 4 games of the 2002 Finals. I'm sure there are others, but I've already made a prison bitch out of your point, so why bother?