Is silence of the lambs a great film? | Page 3 | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Sho Nuff
New Orleans Saints Fan
Hawaii
Member since Feb 2009
5422 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

What kind of great?

An overall amazing, historically important and influential film? No, not at all.

A great mix of writing, acting, editing, etc.? Eh, probably so, but maybe not. It's certainly a character piece and it is great at that. Not sure the rest is really up to snuff. But it's debatable.




People make me laugh. Yeah, the movie is just ok






Back to top
dawgdayafternoon
Georgia Fan
Member since Jul 2011
10027 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


Other than the hairstyle and working with the FBI, I don't see a big connection.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
RollTide1987
Alabama Fan
Aurora, CO
Member since Nov 2009
26016 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

A great mix of writing, acting, editing, etc.? Eh, probably so, but maybe not.


It most definitely is. Anthony Hopkins, Jodie Foster, Ted Levine, and Scott Glenn all did excellent jobs. The film was also well-written and well-directed.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
iwyLSUiwy
Southern Fan
I'm your huckleberry
Member since Apr 2008
21335 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


One of the best movies of all time.



I don't even see hot this can be debatable ...

quote:

A great mix of writing, acting, editing, etc.?




*i haven't read the whole thread yet






Back to top
MrFreakinMiyagi
Stetson Fan
Tampa Bay
Member since Feb 2007
13049 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


Great flick.

I can't think of any flaws with SotL, honestly.






Back to top
la_birdman
LSU Fan
Lake Charles
Member since Feb 2005
16423 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


Great movie. I never get tired of watching it.





Back to top
Fox Mulder
Tulane Fan
Austin, TX
Member since Dec 2010
28160 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


I do remember how they framed the dialogue, it was obnoxious. What I'm really asking is...is SotL great based solely on the merits of Anthony Hopkins' performance

It's an effin iconic character



This post was edited on 3/18 at 11:12 pm


Back to top
REG861
Vanderbilt Fan
New Orleans
Member since Oct 2011
18639 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


have yall ever heard the song 'Goodbye Horses' outside of the movie? God that is some creepy shit, even on its own





Back to top
iwyLSUiwy
Southern Fan
I'm your huckleberry
Member since Apr 2008
21335 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


No not solely on that at all. Jame Gumb is always overlooked bc of Hannibal but he is right on par with him or maybe better.

The connection between Hannibal and Starling is unique. I love the quote "you know they're going to say we're in love" (might not have quoted that exactly but..). He had a genuine interest in her and wanted to help just by getting to hear her history. Someone that the entire world considers a monster wants to help poor little Clarice solve a crime. Better than any love story could have been. You see his true genius too.







Back to top
Blue Velvet
Colorado State Fan
Apple butter toast is nice
Member since Nov 2009
18093 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

One of the best movies of all time.
I agree, definitely in the top 1,000.






Back to top
JombieZombie
Alabama Fan
North Alabama
Member since Nov 2009
4531 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


It's not Citizen Kane or anything, but yes... it's a great film.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sho Nuff
New Orleans Saints Fan
Hawaii
Member since Feb 2009
5422 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

I agree, definitely in the top 1,000.



You couldn't name 200 better films. IMO, it's in the top 100 films of all time and probably a good bit higher.



This post was edited on 3/19 at 4:19 am


Back to top
Bloodworth
New Orleans Saints Fan
North Ga
Member since Oct 2007
1934 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


Demme pretty much nailed the casting of Foster and Hopkins as main characters. Can you imagine anybody else playing Starling or Lecter?

Thomas Harris got exponentially richer off of this film!






Back to top
Freauxzen
USA Fan
Utah
Member since Feb 2006
22299 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

People make me laugh. Yeah, the movie is just ok


Eh, I didn't say the movie was ok at all, I said two things:

It's greatness overall, as a Top 100, or even worse, Top 50, is out of the question. As said above, it isn't Citizen Kane. It also isn't Metropolis, Seven Samurai, The Godfather, or any number of truly great films.

Yes there are 100, probably more than 200 truly better films, at least. (Let's see where it fits on our Top 200 thread).

Secondly, its "greatness" through quality of "parts" is debatable. I'd probably be on the side of "pretty good," but I'm admittedly overly harsh on film. I feel a film really has to connect, has to be perfect in multiple ways to be a great film. SotL falls just short for me.

And no one can say if it's perfect as a fact, so I admit, it's debatable, and I certainly be up for the debate.






Back to top
Freauxzen
USA Fan
Utah
Member since Feb 2006
22299 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

What I'm really asking is...is SotL great based solely on the merits of Anthony Hopkins' performance


If this is the question, then the answer is no. Easily. A one-trick pony is never great. Now if we argue for importance to pop culture, maybe there's an argument, but if this is the question, there are other movie that have better film qualities and better singular actors.

There are 50 films with wonderful performances where the film is absolute mediocrity. SotL isn't mediocre, so there's that. It isn't great either.

The problem I see is that we often react like this for every film, it is the way of the internet. "SotL is a great film!" "The Gladiator is a great film!" "Lincoln was a great film!"

We have named what 1000 great films? What's the point of greatness if everything is great save for Epic Movie and Brown Bunny?



This post was edited on 3/19 at 8:01 am


Back to top
  Replies (0)
RollTide1987
Alabama Fan
Aurora, CO
Member since Nov 2009
26016 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

What I'm really asking is...is SotL great based solely on the merits of Anthony Hopkins' performance


No. While Anthony Hopkins delivered an iconic performance in the role of Hannibal Lecter, you have to remember he was only in the film for 16 minutes of the film's 118 minute run time.

Johnathan Demme did a brilliant job directing the film, particularly the scenes between Clarice and Hannibal and most especially the final confrontation in Buffalo Bill's basement.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Blue Velvet
Colorado State Fan
Apple butter toast is nice
Member since Nov 2009
18093 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

Eh, I didn't say the movie was ok at all, I said two things:

It's greatness overall, as a Top 100, or even worse, Top 50, is out of the question. As said above, it isn't Citizen Kane. It also isn't Metropolis, Seven Samurai, The Godfather, or any number of truly great films.

Yes there are 100, probably more than 200 truly better films, at least. (Let's see where it fits on our Top 200 thread).

Secondly, its "greatness" through quality of "parts" is debatable. I'd probably be on the side of "pretty good," but I'm admittedly overly harsh on film. I feel a film really has to connect, has to be perfect in multiple ways to be a great film. SotL falls just short for me.

And no one can say if it's perfect as a fact, so I admit, it's debatable, and I certainly be up for the debate.
The voice of reason in a world gone to hell.






Back to top
Freauxzen
USA Fan
Utah
Member since Feb 2006
22299 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

Demme pretty much nailed the casting of Foster and Hopkins as main characters. Can you imagine anybody else playing Starling or Lecter?


I'd argue Brian Cox is just as good, if not better, than Hopkins. And I do like Hopkins' take on Lecter, Cox is a bit different though, and far more menacing .

The "cultural" effect of Lecter's portrayal, (which mostly came from the odd sensibilities he gave Lecter, and voice) allowed it to overshadow great work from Cox and a really wonderful take on the same character.






Back to top
Tiger Ryno
USA Fan
Member since Feb 2007
55785 posts
 Online 

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

The "cultural" effect of Lecter's portrayal, (which mostly came from the odd sensibilities he gave Lecter, and voice) allowed it to overshadow great work from Cox and a really wonderful take on the same character.








Back to top
TDTGodfather
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2007
5853 posts

re: Is silence of the lambs a great film?


quote:

silence of the lambs a great film?

loved it






Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top