With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys - Page 12 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

That's humbling for older guys. Believe me. I turned 30 less than 2 months ago and my father's pushing 70. They hang on to old athletes and old actors and past times like mother's milk. Nothing to resent really. Just the way it is.


I don't resent it, but don't expect me to not point out the huge flaw in their line of thinking. I turn 30 next year, fwiw.






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

Yea...the quality of a black and white television is just as comparable to a flat screen HDTV...


It was the best for the time period. Everyone in the field has access to the same equipment, thus the playing field is leveled for superior skill to take over.

Now if someone was trying to compare Tiger and Jack both shooting 64 in their primes on the exact same course and layout, then equipment is a factor. But for the purpose of GOAT discussions, equipment is irrelevant.



This post was edited on 3/11 at 12:56 pm


Back to top
unbeWEAVEable
LSU Fan
Golf Board
Member since Apr 2010
11439 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

But for the purpose of GOAT discussions, equipment is irrelevant.


I see that as obtuse, but we all have our opinions.






Back to top
lsugolf1105
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Aug 2008
3264 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

It was the best for the time period. Everyone in the field has access to the same equipment, thus the playing field is leveled for superior skill to take over.


the new equipment is more forgiving and easier to hit straight. i guarantee you that tiger wishes everyone was hitting with hickory shafts and feather balls.






Back to top
LSUdm21
LSU Fan
Member since Nov 2008
17451 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

the new equipment is more forgiving and easier to hit straight. i guarantee you that tiger wishes everyone was hitting with hickory shafts and feather balls.


And courses are longer and more challenging now. Also, I'd LOVE to see Tiger go all out with a hickory shaft.






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

I see that as obtuse, but we all have our opinions.


Feel free to disprove my logic.






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

the new equipment is more forgiving and easier to hit straight. i guarantee you that tiger wishes everyone was hitting with hickory shafts and feather balls.


So by this, you've just admitted that more people can win a tournament today compared to when the equipment was not as good. Which therefore makes Tiger's run more impressive.






Back to top
iheartlsu
USA Fan
70820
Member since Sep 2005
25194 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


Does it really matter how forgiving equipment is when every pro has wear marks like this.




This post was edited on 3/11 at 3:21 pm


Back to top
lsugolf1105
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Aug 2008
3264 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

So by this, you've just admitted that more people can win a tournament today compared to when the equipment was not as good. Which therefore makes Tiger's run more impressive.


yes. that is exactly what i am saying.






Back to top
unbeWEAVEable
LSU Fan
Golf Board
Member since Apr 2010
11439 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


Do you legitimately not see how ignorant that is? I'm not going to explain myself if you aren't serious.





Back to top
BRgetthenet
Golf Board Smash Lab™ CEO
Member since Oct 2011
57808 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


My next 8 iron will look like that.








Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

It was the best for the time period. Everyone in the field has access to the same equipment, thus the playing field is leveled for superior skill to take over.

Now if someone was trying to compare Tiger and Jack both shooting 64 in their primes on the exact same course and layout, then equipment is a factor. But for the purpose of GOAT discussions, equipment is irrelevant.


Refute this. I don't think you can.






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

Does it really matter how forgiving equipment is when every pro has wear marks like this


This too.






Back to top
lsugolf1105
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Aug 2008
3264 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

Refute this. I don't think you can.


you can miss the center of the club face and still hit a good shot with today's equipment. if you missed the center of the club face with the old equipment, you were screwed.






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

you can miss the center of the club face and still hit a good shot with today's equipment. if you missed the center of the club face with the old equipment, you were screwed.


How does that refute my statement exactly?






Back to top
lsugolf1105
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Aug 2008
3264 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

How does that refute my statement exactly?


superior skill is diminished.






Back to top
hehateme2285
LSU Fan
Katy, TX
Member since Dec 2007
3196 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

Does it really matter how forgiving equipment is when every pro has wear marks like this


It's not about the majority, it's about the one you miss that doesn't fly off the planet or land 80 yards short






Back to top
LNCHBOX
LSU Fan
70001
Member since Jun 2009
16960 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

superior skill is diminished


What are you even talking about?

Everyone has access to the same high tech equipment for a given time period. Therefore there is no equipment advantage when comparing Tiger's run with Jack's run. Tiger uses the same equipment his competitors use, and Jack used the same equipment his competitors used.

Anyone arguing that Tiger's run is somehow diminished because of equipment advances is most likely retarded.






Back to top
lsugolf1105
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Aug 2008
3264 posts

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


quote:

Anyone arguing that Tiger's run is somehow diminished because of equipment advances is most likely retarded.


i'm arguing that it is more impressive because less talented players are capable of winning. a guy can miss a shot and still get away with it.






Back to top
beaverfever
Arkansas Fan
Little Rock
Member since Jan 2008
7610 posts
 Online 

re: With Tiger's win today, that gives him 7 wins in his last 22 PGA Tourneys


Tiger's status as the best amateur golfer ever (shout out to bobby jones) is what makes him the GOAT already IMO. I don't count his us amateur titles as majors but they are not second rate titles and I do put them in their own category of achievements to be compared.





Back to top


Back to top




//