Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so... | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Scoop
LSU Fan
Where you live
Member since Sep 2005
26506 posts

Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


What an amazing slide from the first season to the second.

The first season was some of the best TV I've seen. The second season was not even close to as good.

It became 24 in the second season and not in a good way. 24 was an entertaining show but it had the maddening tendency to have the characters do things completely illogical that no one would do in a million years for no other reason than to get the storyline where the writers needed it to be.

That's what screwed up Homeland in season 2. There were plot holes that you could drop an aircraft carrier into that only existed because the writers couldn't get from A to C without a ridiculous B.

I'll probably give season 3 a chance but it was such a let down going from season 1 to 2.




This post was edited on 2/5 at 3:56 pm



Back to top
Share:
JawjaTigah
LSU Fan
South of Tampa
Member since Sep 2003
10779 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

What an amazing slide from the first season to the second.

The first season was some of the best TV I've seen. The second season was not even close to as good.
A lot of transitioning, but I have to mostly agree with your assessment. One season to redeem itself, or I'm on to other, better things.






Back to top
JB Bama
Alabama Fan
Tuscaloosa, AL
Member since Sep 2008
2019 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Spoilers:







Once that Keri saw that video early in the season they had to stretch the imagination to make you believe she would still fall for Brody, and the idea that you could have 2 season finales where she's questioning whether Brodie was behind the terrorist plot is absurd.



This post was edited on 2/5 at 4:01 pm


Back to top
Scoop
LSU Fan
Where you live
Member since Sep 2005
26506 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Spoiler












An annoying example is having Saul flown out to a ship to watch Nazeer's body get dumped into the ocean which made no sense but was just a lame reason to not have him at the Langley bombing. That's a minor one but fresh on my mind.






Back to top
LarryDavid
Maryland Fan
Los Angeles
Member since Sep 2010
2571 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Nothing so far is completely "absurd" enough to support the OP's missive. I'm interested to hear this list of things that are so unbelievable so many people say are wrong with season 2, but I have yet to see anyone actually write. So as Harry Caray would say (slurring) "LET ME HEAR YA, A ONE, AND A TWO AND A ..."





Back to top
dallastiger55
LSU Fan
Jennings, LA
Member since Jan 2010
3903 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Season 2 is better. Critics and fans rate it higher than season 1. Check the sites





Back to top
Fearthehat0307
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
45139 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


i loved season 1 and season 2. i enjoyed 2 more





Back to top
LarryDavid
Maryland Fan
Los Angeles
Member since Sep 2010
2571 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

Season 2 is better. Critics and fans rate it higher than season 1. Check the sites


Everywhere but here, that's why I want to hear their reasons instead of just saying it had so many holes in the plots. I'd like to hear these "giant" holes.






Back to top
R2Z2
Member since Dec 2012
115 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Season 2 has more action. They just won a bunch of awards.





Back to top
dallastiger55
LSU Fan
Jennings, LA
Member since Jan 2010
3903 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Season 2 starts off with a bang and never let's up. I enjoyed the new guy who was working for Estes and the whole Gettysburg storyline.





Back to top
Billy Mays
Ole Miss Fan
The Northshore, Brah...
Member since Jan 2009
15721 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Season 1 set the bar so damn high.

Hard to match it, IMO.






Back to top
Wolf
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2005
632 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

Season 2 is better. Critics and fans rate it higher than season 1. Check the sites


This. After all the shite I heard here about how the second season is worse than the first I started the show fully prepared to be disappointed. When I found the second season to actually be more entertaining I was surprised. So I guess I have this board to thank for that






Back to top
lsuguy13
LSU Fan
Tha Present
Member since Mar 2004
7006 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


What were sone plot holes





Back to top
Wolf
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2005
632 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


I am willing to make allowances for plot holes if the show at least makes an effort to make it semi believable (or at least not completely impossible).Homeland has not yet dipped into 24 territory so I am ok with it as long as it is entertaining and it is absolutely that





Back to top
Decatur
USA Fan
Member since Mar 2007
17275 posts
 Online 

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

Spoiler












An annoying example is having Saul flown out to a ship to watch Nazeer's body get dumped into the ocean which made no sense but was just a lame reason to not have him at the Langley bombing.


Spoiler














Me thinks Saul knew that the bombing was going down, might have planned it himself...he's my top candidate for the mole right now

















This post was edited on 2/5 at 7:34 pm


Back to top
Scoop
LSU Fan
Where you live
Member since Sep 2005
26506 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


The prayer he was making amongst the bodies in the last minute of the S2 finale was in Yiddish. I wonder what kind of prayer it was.

Interesting.






Back to top
Bunta
LSU Fan
Captain Lu-Natic
Member since Oct 2007
6011 posts
 Online 

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Spoiler


















How about Carrie disappearing after the bombing and then showing up later like nothing happened?






Back to top
LarryDavid
Maryland Fan
Los Angeles
Member since Sep 2010
2571 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

How about Carrie disappearing after the bombing and then showing up later like nothing happened?


That was the very last scene. How is that a hole? We don't even have a clue how that is going to play out in season 3.


Still waiting.






Back to top
Bunta
LSU Fan
Captain Lu-Natic
Member since Oct 2007
6011 posts
 Online 

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


Spoilers


















She just walks through every agent that still had to be there and went directly to Saul without being stopped and questioned on her whereabouts?



This post was edited on 2/5 at 8:15 pm


Back to top
LarryDavid
Maryland Fan
Los Angeles
Member since Sep 2010
2571 posts

re: Thoughts after watching Homeland over the last week or so...


quote:

She just walks through every agent that still had to be there and went directly to Saul without being stopped and questioned on her whereabouts?


Everybody is pretty much dead. Any new "agents" there would let her see Saul because he's pretty much in charge now and she's always been number one in his mind. I don't see that as much of a stretch.






Back to top



Back to top