|
| Posted by | Message | Tiger in Texas 
Ohio State Fan
Houston, Texas
Member since Sep 2004
11007 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 12:26 pm to Jester)
quote:
Roger. Pink Floyd without him became extremely boring.
Final Cut was the one vinyl Floyd album with Waters I didn't buy, and certainly don't regret it- musically, was just not happening...
To me, the music is always more important that lyric context, so I have to go with Gilmore, especially considering his solo albums...
| | Back to top | | diddydirtyAubie
Member since Dec 2010
24999 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 1:34 pm to tigerpimpbot)
I would say Waters all day.
| | Back to top | | The Dude's Rug 
LSU Fan
Fourside
Member since Nov 2004
3496 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 1:40 pm to diddydirtyAubie)
quote:
I would say Waters all day.
Care to explain your reasoning? I'm just curious. 
| | Back to top | | urinetrouble
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2007
10533 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 2:04 pm to Tiger in Texas)
quote:
To me, the music is always more important that lyric context, so I have to go with Gilmore, especially considering his solo albums...
If you're saying the music is most important, than that is not necessarily a reason to favor Waters. People keep acting like Waters' only contribution was lyrics.
He was the primary songwriter which includes creative conception of the chord progression, rhythm, vocal melodies, musical riffs, etc. as well as the great lyrics.
| | Back to top | | parrotdr
LSU Fan
Cesspool of Rationalization
Member since Oct 2003
5275 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 7:06 pm to urinetrouble)
Waters here.
| | Back to top | | Da #1 Stunna
LSU Fan
985
Member since Oct 2012
187 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/6/13 at 10:21 pm to SUB)
Gilmour without question.
| | Back to top | |
Back to top
|
