Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
tigerpimpbot
LA-Monroe Fan
The 561
Member since Nov 2011
26206 posts

Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Who do you prefer?

Singing and guitar vs. lyrics and arrangement







Back to top
Share:
BRUNNIN4
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2010
2248 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour





Back to top
tigerpimpbot
LA-Monroe Fan
The 561
Member since Nov 2011
26206 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


I agree





Back to top
Ryne Sandberg
USA Fan
Team Am Mart
Member since Apr 2009
17857 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


David Gilmour because he's not a whiny twat.





Back to top
mograyback
Missouri Fan
Member since Jul 2011
7102 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour.





Back to top
The Dude's Rug
LSU Fan
Gerdzfa
Member since Nov 2004
7881 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour in every category.

Waters is a weird frick.






Back to top
squirtis42
Mississippi St. Fan
Member since Sep 2012
42 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour no doubt.





Back to top
CocoLoco
New Orleans Saints Fan
30° 12' N 92° 0' W
Member since Jan 2012
12199 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour is magic





Back to top
White Shadeaux
LSU Fan
In the nicest parts of hell
Member since Jan 2006
23097 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


I like their collaborations, but Waters' personal little child angst therapy moments just about ruin The Wall for me.

Gilmour all the way.






Back to top
CottonWasKing
LSU Fan
4,8,15,16,23,42
Member since Jun 2011
15127 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour





Back to top
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
17459 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


I prefer Roger. Pink Floyd without him became extremely boring.





Back to top
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
17459 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


quote:

Gilmour in every category.


Gilmour is nowhere near the songwriter that Waters is.






Back to top
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
17459 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


quote:

David Gilmour......not a whiny twat.





The problem with Floyd was that both of them are arrogant pricks.






Back to top
xgd
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Nov 2010
306 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


quote:

Gilmour is nowhere near the songwriter that Waters is.






Back to top
Scruffy
USA Fan
Member since Jul 2011
25879 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Both are great in their own way. As of late, I'd probably go with Gilmour since I've been enjoying Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell.





Back to top
White Shadeaux
LSU Fan
In the nicest parts of hell
Member since Jan 2006
23097 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


quote:

Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell.


But wait....Jester says those are extremely boring.






Back to top
PuntBamaPunt
Vanderbilt Fan
Member since Nov 2010
5993 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


I like both of those albums but they aren't near the albums the group as a whole put out.

To claim Gilmour is a better songwriter than Waters is absurd.






Back to top
legba
Alabama Fan
at the crossroads
Member since Oct 2010
521 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Waters, but only by a hair. I would hate anaimals if not for Dave's guitar work





Back to top
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
17459 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


quote:

I like both of those albums but they aren't near the albums the group as a whole put out.

To claim Gilmour is a better songwriter than Waters is absurd.


Exactly. FWIW, I own both albums and don't dislike them. They are just not on par with previous work. Quite frankly, they are the Pink Floyd albums I am most likely to play to help me fall asleep at night.

The Division Bell is actually the first album on my "Sleepytime" playlist.



This post was edited on 1/4 at 9:17 am


Back to top
SUB
LSU Fan
Member since Jan 2009
3070 posts

re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour


Gilmour has a great voice but Rogers is a better song writer. I like the combination of them both.





Back to top



Back to top