Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album - Page 3 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Kubricked
Member since Nov 2012
302 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Marquee Moon has been on top 100 album lists since the 80s.

Villiage Green is as well but at the time of its initial release it was certainly out of step with the counterculture 60s. It celebrates and mythologized the past.






Back to top
Kubricked
Member since Nov 2012
302 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Not an album but a single worth mention on this thread. Ike and Tina Turner's River Deep, Mountain High.

Produced by Phil Spector, who was convinced it was a #1 the record was deemed too soulful for white radio and too white for black stations.

One of the all-time great singles.






Back to top
Wrenchruh
Alabama Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Sep 2012
998 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


quote:

Metallica - Load. I dont care what anyone says, its a great hard rock album. If it were released by Soundgarden or AIC, people would call it a classic


Good God you've done it now. That album isn't hated enough. If Soundgarden or AiC put that album out, it probably wouldn't have sucked nearly as bad because those bands could pull that off. The problem with Load is, is that Metallica wanted to make a record that they were completely incapable of making. It just wasn't in their DNA. The whole thing is a collection of songs in styles that they enjoyed, but had no business writing. Awful.

Props to you for standing by it. You've got balls. I like balls.






Back to top
AlxTgr
LSU Fan
Kyre Banorg
Member since Oct 2003
33603 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


quote:

I like balls.
I bet you do, cowboy.






Back to top
lpgreat1
LSU Fan
Monroe, LA
Member since Nov 2007
899 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


I think Pinkerton pretty much personifies this thread. Everyone gives it five stars now, as it deserves, but everyone hated it when it came out. Critics, fans, even Rivers Cuomo hated it.

Many albums that followed a band's "great" album fall into this category. They are always seen as inferior if they follow a "classic" no matter if on its own it's still a great record.

Green Day's Insomniac jumps to the front of my mind.






Back to top
TigersMaul Bammers
LSU Fan
Normandy Park, WA
Member since Apr 2009
518 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Wowee Zowee by Pavement.

I didn't get it until I heard their next album.






Back to top
Chef Leppard
Georgia Fan
Member since Sep 2011
8141 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Good one. excellent album

Gets way too overshadowed by slanted/enchanted






Back to top
TDTGodfather
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2007
5388 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


quote:

I remember most people not liking Faith No More's album King For a Day, Fool for a Lifetime but its got some of their best songs. A lot of people say Metallica sold out with the black album but commercial sounding or not, I think its great.

totally agree.

for me, it was nirvana's in utero. it was still loved but not as much as nevermind.

even upon my 1st listen in didn't like save for a couple of songs and the more i listened the more i like it. same with superunknown after badmotorfinger with soundgarden






Back to top
mizzoukills
Member since Aug 2011
22723 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Tool - "10,000 Days" album

This will get a lot of flack, but here's why I list it. I'm a huge Tool fan. Most Tool fans hated this album compared to Tool's 90s work.

However, the more you listen to it, the more brilliant it is.

In fact, I spent about 4 months listening to nothing but "Rosetta Stoned" on repeat. I'm now convinced that "Rosetta Stoned" is one of the most epic songs ever made and in my opinion it's Tool's best.

Therefore...I went from thinking that 10,000 Days was Tool's weakest album (though, to put this into persepective, if it was released by any other band, it would be epic) to thinking that certain parts of 10,000 Days is Tool's greatest accomplishment to date.




This post was edited on 12/13 at 11:55 am


Back to top
Wrenchruh
Alabama Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Sep 2012
998 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Have you heard it when you play Vigenti Tres and Wings for Marie Part 1 back to back over wings for Marie part 2? shite syncs up.

Also Eulogy and Third Eye>>>>>>>anything on 10000 Days. I will have to give it another listen soon though. It's been a minute.






Back to top
mizzoukills
Member since Aug 2011
22723 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Wrenchruh,

Just listen to number 8 "Rosetta Stoned". But, first read the lyrics. You'll get why the song is insanely awesome on top of it being masterfully hard and badass.

Their most badass song to date. Period. Nothing beats it.

Actually, listen to song 7 leading into 8.






Back to top
Wrenchruh
Alabama Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Sep 2012
998 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


Oh I know the album well. Lost keys, blame Hoffman setting the narrative. It's just been a while since I heard it. I agree that Rossetta Stoned is the highlight of the album.
I just feel that Eulogy is probably the best song ever recorded. By anyone.

Cheers







Back to top
mizzoukills
Member since Aug 2011
22723 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album








Back to top
Wrenchruh
Alabama Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Sep 2012
998 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


My album is Slayer's Divine Intervention. It's their first with Lombardo on the drums and a lot of fans aren't fond of it. I absolutely love it. I think it's better than Reign in Blood, which IMO is a bunch of filler bookended by greatness.





Back to top
Progress
Alabama Fan
Birmingham
Member since Nov 2012
245 posts

re: Most Misunderstood or Poorly Received Great Album


quote:

Suicide's suicide






Back to top


Back to top