1908 National Champions - Page 2 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
The Mick
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2010
22303 posts
 Online 

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

This question comes up every so often around here. If you are serious, I would contact the athletic department and LSU to see if you can get some information.
Although Im going by foggy memory alone, Im sticking with my reason. LSU doesnt claim it b/c players were paid and some were not students.






Back to top
LSUsCRYSTALball
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2012
1702 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

I mean, c'mon Carlisle Indian School?


QUOTE FROM NEXT CENTURY:
"I mean, c'mon LSU and Alabama played football in the early 2000's? HA I only thought they knew how to play ultimate frisbee"






Back to top
Tchefuncte Tiger
LSU Fan
Bat'n Rudge
Member since Oct 2004
23046 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

I mean, c'mon Carlisle Indian School?


Was Jim Thorpe on this team?






Back to top
  Replies (0)
RedStar
Alabama Fan
Member since Aug 2011
61 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

QUOTE FROM NEXT CENTURY:
"I mean, c'mon LSU and Alabama played football in the early 2000's? HA I only thought they knew how to play ultimate frisbee"


Do you guys not read past the original post?






Back to top
nvasil1
LSU Fan
Chicago
Member since Oct 2009
1962 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


If A&M can retroactively claim 2 NCs, we can legitimately claim 1908.





Back to top
RedStar
Alabama Fan
Member since Aug 2011
61 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

If A&M can retroactively claim 2 NCs, we can legitimately claim 1908.


That's all I'm saying. And it's not so much claiming them as it is acknowledging that it was awarded. It's not like this is just a made up fact. LSU was awarded a National Championship in 1908, why the hell shouldn't it be acknowledged?






Back to top
LSUsCRYSTALball
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2012
1702 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


Lets claim it





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Phoenix43
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2012
156 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


If we played it and won it then we should acknowledge it and add it to the list of the ones we have won. Apparently LSU did what needed to be done to be deemed champions so I say add it, JMO.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
JollyGreenGiant
Michigan State Fan
The Help Board
Member since Jul 2004
24150 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


If I'm not mistaken, we don't claim it because we were awarded that title retroactively. Unlike Bama (several of theirs were awarded retroactively), we don't claim it. We have titles in '35 and '36 we don't claim for similar reasons.





Back to top
athletemed
LSU Fan
The Woodlands, Texas
Member since Oct 2007
5471 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


because the 1908 team, lead by Doc Fenton could have legitimately been considered a professional team at the time...

Fenton was "heavy recruited" to come to LSU which meant money, whores and booze....

not that there is anything wrong with that...






Back to top
nvasil1
LSU Fan
Chicago
Member since Oct 2009
1962 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

because the 1908 team, lead by Doc Fenton could have legitimately been considered a professional team at the time...

There's that too, not to mention southern football obviously didn't have the same reputation back in that day.

Also, I've read in the past that Penn, Harvard and UChicago were all clearly better than LSU in '08.

But hey, if the NCF thinks we deserve a share of that title, the school might as well too.






Back to top
Pilot Tiger
Georgetown Fan
Washington DC
Member since Nov 2005
60757 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

Also, I've read in the past that Penn, Harvard and UChicago were all clearly better than LSU in '08.
this is very debatable







Back to top
LSUsCRYSTALball
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2012
1702 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

Fenton was "heavy recruited" to come to LSU which meant money, whores and booze....


... Isn't that why we all came here






Back to top
  Replies (0)
2geaux
LSU Fan
Georgia
Member since Feb 2008
613 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


Carlisle was a big deal then. They had Jim Thorpe!





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Me Bite
LSU Fan
A.K.A. - Bite Me
Member since Oct 2007
6610 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

Sure it's a split title, but so is 2003 and no one has a problem claiming it




You don't know much about college football...



This post was edited on 12/11 at 8:57 am


Back to top
RedStar
Alabama Fan
Member since Aug 2011
61 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

We have titles in '35 and '36 we don't claim for similar reasons.


'35 & '36 weren't handed out by the National Championship Foundation.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
nvasil1
LSU Fan
Chicago
Member since Oct 2009
1962 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

this is very debatable

No doubt it's debatable.

Here's a decent article that breaks down the cases for each team in '08.

LINK

ETA: This part of the article cracked me up...
quote:

LSU is not even a legitimate contender. But to the school's credit, they do not claim this "national championship." Alabama would already have made the banners and rings by now if it were them.



This post was edited on 12/11 at 9:05 am


Back to top
RedStar
Alabama Fan
Member since Aug 2011
61 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:



You don't know much about college football...


Is there anything I said in that post that's wrong?






Back to top
  Replies (0)
RedStar
Alabama Fan
Member since Aug 2011
61 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


quote:

No doubt it's debatable.

Here's a decent article that breaks down the cases for each team in '08.

LINK


Hm... not sure how I feel about it. Seems like he did some research, but unless he was alive in 1908, I doubt he actually saw any of those teams play. At the end of the day, he's just a blogger. He has a valid opinion, but it's no more valuable than yours or mine.

If the National Championship Foundation saw fit to award the 1908 National Title to LSU, I see no reason the football program shouldn't acknowledge it.

Plus acknowledging it is a way of validating LSU throughout the course of CFB history. It shows that LSU has always been good, unlike some flash in the pan program like Florida who's only been relevant since the 90's.






Back to top
TenTex
LSU Fan
Member since Jan 2008
14306 posts

re: 1908 National Champions


Alabama and USCw exaggerate their NC's. Our 2003 was a BCS National Championship. Our 3 are rock solid!





Back to top


Back to top