Was this the one that let them be captains in PE. That was my second favorite episode and very uplifting.
That one was great too. Bill playing shortstop and Sam pitching. I love that Bill calls a timeout and Sam says "Bill that's all I got". Then bill makes a pretty good catch and they all bum rush him and the jerk dude is like "It's the first out of the game you idiots"
The episode I was talking about is when they went to the party and played spin the bottle and bill got to make out with the chick in the closet. Best moment of the entire series IMO. Bill is so freaking genuine you love that he gets something good happen to him. Then Neil is knocking on the door saying "this is the worst party ever"