Teams to root for this week/weekend - Page 3 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
NorthGwinnettTiger
Auburn Fan
Member since Jun 2006
34682 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

LINK?


LINK






Back to top
LaBornNRaised
LSU Fan
The Datty's are Fixed!
Member since Feb 2011
9907 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


I liked the Math.com link better. It was "less subtle".





Back to top
  Replies (0)
misterdavamoto
Iona Fan
Lakeview Proper
Member since Sep 2007
603 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

The odds of you getting a wild card are exponentially higher than a 9-1 Falcons team tanking the season.


Math is admittedly not my strong suit, but i do know the definitions of the words I openly use.






Back to top
misterdavamoto
Iona Fan
Lakeview Proper
Member since Sep 2007
603 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend








Back to top
Sophandros
Tulane Fan
Victoria Concordia Crescit
Member since Feb 2005
45154 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

So cut your nose off to spite your face?


You really are stupid.

Because of how things are laid out, the Saints will most likely have to win out AND get some help in order to make the playoffs.

SO:

The goal is to win the division; if you don't, then and only then do you think about the wildcard. The way for that to happen is for the Saints to win out (again, which will likely be necessary to make the playoffs) AND for Atlanta to lose an additional 3 games.

In ANY scenario in which the Saints win out, they hold the tie breaker over Tampa by virtue of sweeping them, so their winning any additional games other than against the Saints is meaningless. Because Tampa's playing good football right now, they would be a good candidate to beat the Falcons.

Thus, you pull for Tampa to win if you want the Saints to have the best possible chance of making the playoffs. When and if Atlanta clinches the division, you start looking at Wild Card matchups.






Back to top
NorthGwinnettTiger
Auburn Fan
Member since Jun 2006
34682 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


I provided you a link showing how you had a less than 1% mathematical chance to win the division, and a 10% chance of winning a wild card spot. And you're wanting to turn this into a discussion on verbiage. Sorry, but it's not going to happen. The fact of the matter is that a Bucs win does in fact hurt your chances of making the playoffs in the grand scheme of things, despite what you have convinced yourself.





Back to top
Sophandros
Tulane Fan
Victoria Concordia Crescit
Member since Feb 2005
45154 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


If Tampa wins this weekend, and if the Saints win next Thursday night, the Saints are two games back and would hold the tiebreaker over the Falcons.

THAT is why Saints fans should pull for a Tampa win.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
NorthGwinnettTiger
Auburn Fan
Member since Jun 2006
34682 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

Because of how things are laid out, the Saints will most likely have to win out AND get some help in order to make the playoffs.



So the 11-5 Saints would need help to make the playoffs?






Back to top
quail man
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New York, NY
Member since May 2010
25330 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


the problem is that you are being extremely narrow minded. you are looking at one possible way that it works out without giving any credit to the fact that there are other ways. we are looking at another, one that is easier and mathematically more realistic. your way is based on the Saints winning out. ours is based on the Saints losing one game.

either way, we need to the saints to win this weekend, and it will get more clear after this week what else we need to happen.






Back to top
NorthGwinnettTiger
Auburn Fan
Member since Jun 2006
34682 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

the problem is that you are being extremely narrow minded. you are looking at one possible way that it works out without giving any credit to the fact that there are other ways. we are looking at another, one that is easier and mathematically more realistic. your way is based on the Saints winning out. ours is based on the Saints losing one game.


Ding ding ding. The idea that a 5-5 team is gonna go 6-0, versus maybe it's more likely they go 4-2. And a 9-7 Saints team needs a whole helluva lot less parity in the league.






Back to top
Sophandros
Tulane Fan
Victoria Concordia Crescit
Member since Feb 2005
45154 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

So the 11-5 Saints would need help to make the playoffs?


Yes. Because Seattle is currently the #6 seed at 6-4. It's conceivable that there could be a 12-4 team at #6, so regardless the Saints would need help to get in at 11-5.






Back to top
quail man
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New York, NY
Member since May 2010
25330 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

The idea that a 5-5 team is gonna go 6-0


it's not even that. the saints are, what, 5-1 in their past 6. it's the fact that with the schedule ahead, the Saints have MAYBE 2 games that are likely wins. the rest are very tough. it's more likely that they lose 1, and that would all but mathematically eliminate them from the division.

i get where sophandros is coming from. i really do. but I just can't see it happening. so i'm pulling for the scenario that is MORE likely.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
NorthGwinnettTiger
Auburn Fan
Member since Jun 2006
34682 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:


Yes. Because Seattle is currently the #6 seed at 6-4. It's conceivable that there could be a 12-4 team at #6, so regardless the Saints would need help to get in at 11-5.


So a 5-5 team and a 6-4 team are gonna go 12-0 in your "scenario"? Got it.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
misterdavamoto
Iona Fan
Lakeview Proper
Member since Sep 2007
603 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

I provided you a link showing how you had a less than 1% mathematical chance to win the division, and a 10% chance of winning a wild card spot. And you're wanting to turn this into a discussion on verbiage. Sorry, but it's not going to happen. The fact of the matter is that a Bucs win does in fact hurt your chances of making the playoffs in the grand scheme of things, despite what you have convinced yourself


Actually, your link shows a 14% chance of the Saints making the playoffs today, and in context, (falcons vs bucs this week), calculate the odds following a Saints and Bucs win this weekend; your word usage is hyperbolic at best, but nonetheless incorrect.

I would agree with you, but then we'd both be wrong.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sophandros
Tulane Fan
Victoria Concordia Crescit
Member since Feb 2005
45154 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

the problem is that you are being extremely narrow minded. you are looking at one possible way that it works out without giving any credit to the fact that there are other ways.


No, I'm fully aware of the the other ways to get into the playoffs. However, you must first and foremost try to secure the division. Only after that do you worry about the wild card.

In this situation, the Saints MUST win out, whether or not you're looking at wild card or division.

Because of this, they will have swept the Bucs and the Bucs would have no better than the same record (11-5) as the Saints; the first tiebreaker is head to head, so the Saints would win that. Therefore, my saying to pull for the Bucs IS IN FACT taking your "look to the wildcard" into account.

quote:

we are looking at another, one that is easier and mathematically more realistic.


The Saints have to win out in any situation, so Tampa is out of the equation.

quote:

your way is based on the Saints winning out. ours is based on the Saints losing one game.


If you go in assuming a loss, then you aren't getting into the playoffs.

My assumption is that in order for the Saints to make the playoffs, they must win out. That is the most realistic and easy assumption. One loss, and you can consider us done.






Back to top
misterdavamoto
Iona Fan
Lakeview Proper
Member since Sep 2007
603 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

Sophandros








Back to top
  Replies (0)
Sophandros
Tulane Fan
Victoria Concordia Crescit
Member since Feb 2005
45154 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


I'm not assuming that the Saints WILL go 6-0.

I'm saying that IF the Saints want to make the playoffs, they HAVE TO GO 6-0 AND get some help. Anything less would result in missing the playoffs, IMO.

Now, after this weekend, the assumption set may change, depending on the results. Let's say that the Saints win and Tampa, Minnesota, Dallas, and Seattle all lose. You'd have a log jam of teams at 6-5 AND a win on Thursday night against the Falcons only brings the Saints to within 3 games with 4 to play. That drastically changes the calculus.

But until then, I'm sticking with my assumption set.






Back to top
quail man
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New York, NY
Member since May 2010
25330 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


quote:

However, you must first and foremost try to secure the division. Only after that do you worry about the wild card.


thats where we differ. at this point, my goal is to get the wild card spot because that is more likely. the scenario I outline in the OP would make the saints tied for the last wild card spot. that's what i'm looking for.

again, i completely understand your way. it's spot on, and the more you outline it, the better i understand it. but for me, the goal is wild card and for you the goal is division.

i don't know if my brain can take much more logic and attempts at defending my cause, this is my thanksgiving break finally, a few days off school. my mind needs a break






Back to top
whodatfan
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2008
15328 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


Here is my scenario. Try to win all of your games because that's all you can control. See where the chips fall at the end. Period.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
DoubleDown
Alabama Fan
New Orleans, Louisiana
Member since Oct 2008
3492 posts

re: Teams to root for this week/weekend


You had me at:
Atlanta at Tampa Bay (12:00 PM, FOX) -- Atlanta.

Thanks for the continued support!






Back to top


Back to top