But if you talk to any amount of victims/suspects you get a feel for how humans in general react in certain circumstances.
Ah, good ole' intuition. And what grounds do I have to submit to the authority of your intuition, or anyone's?
Your intuition would have to be confirmed as sound by another party, and then that party's intuition about your intuition would also need to be confirmed, and so on into infinite regress.
How about we leave "hints" and "gut feelings" to the initial investigative proceedings and keep them out of determinations of guilt.
Sorry you were wrong.