Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
classictiger
LSU Fan
Member since Mar 2007
5643 posts

Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


Hands down for me its ATL/StL in terms of level of significance and how clear cut the call was. Oh, and it wasn't replacement officials.






Back to top
Share:
CHEEEEESE
New Orleans Saints Fan
Pres. of the Mike Lowery Fan Club
Member since May 2006
9872 posts
 Online 

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


GB. They had instant replay and still fricked it up.





Back to top
DollaChoppa
LSU Fan
ACC #1 Baseball Conference
Member since May 2008
74051 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


The ATL/STL call was a much easier one to make. With all the time in the world to decide it.

eta: If we consider instant replay, then maybe GB/S



This post was edited on 10/5 at 7:15 pm


Back to top
GeauxTGRZ
LSU Fan
PTal
Member since Oct 2005
3166 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


i knew i would see this thread shortly.

the atlanta game






Back to top
angryslugs
New Orleans Saints Fan
fort worth
Member since Apr 2008
4947 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


As bad as the MNF call was, this one was way worse





Back to top
Supravol22
Tennessee Fan
Member since Jan 2011
9423 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


ATL/StL much more meaningful of a game and the call was just fricking retarded





Back to top
msutiger
Louisiana Tech Fan
Ruston
Member since Jul 2008
47286 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


GB/Seattle

It was actually the difference in the game. ATL is still down 3 runs.






Back to top
lsu13lsu
LSU Fan
Member since Jan 2008
1550 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


ATL/STL bc of significance. This call was bad bad.





Back to top
classictiger
LSU Fan
Member since Mar 2007
5643 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


quote:

GB. They had instant replay and still fricked it up.


Instant replay could only determine whether the ball was caught or not-- not simultaneous possession.






Back to top
Lou
LSU Fan
out here in the middle
Member since Aug 2005
6815 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


They are both horrible. I would lean towards the GB call because it literally cost them the game. Braves would have bases loaded and one out, but still be down three runs. No guarantee they win if the right call is made.





Back to top
Kafka
New Orleans Saints Fan
Remembering The Alamo
Member since Jul 2007
68727 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


quote:

Instant replay could only determine whether the ball was caught or not-- not simultaneous possession

According to SVP replay can determine possession in the end zone






Back to top
DawgCountry
Kennesaw St. Fan
Woodstock
Member since Sep 2012
8166 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


This call. Direct effect on playoffs. Nfl call my or may not effect the playoffs





Back to top
St Augustine
New Orleans Saints Fan
The Pauper of the Surf
Member since Mar 2006
41695 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


GB it directly gave them a loss


This post was edited on 10/5 at 7:39 pm


Back to top
flvelo12
LSU Fan
Clearwater, Florida
Member since Jan 2012
704 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


quote:

They are both horrible. I would lean towards the GB call because it literally cost them the game. Braves would have bases loaded and one out, but still be down three runs. No guarantee they win if the right call is made.


This.






Back to top
acgeaux129
USA Fan
We are BR
Member since Sep 2007
15011 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


I said it in the game thread I'll say it again. Chipper was ridiculously out. Quit bitching.





Back to top
Woopigsooie20
UConn Fan
Me Scusi
Member since Mar 2010
47301 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


Great. We'll hear Braves fans bitch and bitch and bitch until the season starts next year and when they choke again we'll start this over.





Back to top
Tigerfan7218
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2010
7510 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


Some people need to read the rule, if a play is made by an infielder it can be ruled infield fly, regardless of where the catch actually happens. So lets look at the reasonable effort part: dude was camped under the ball until he hears what he believes is a call off from LF and ducks out if the way. The last part is the timely manner part, which I will concede it was a late late call, HOWEVER the ump must make sure it will be a reasonable effort play, hence the delay.

Right call IMO, does it suck for the braves? Yes, but its not why you lost, had 2nd and 3rd in three straight innings.

On that note: GB is the worse call



This post was edited on 10/5 at 7:54 pm


Back to top
Supravol22
Tennessee Fan
Member since Jan 2011
9423 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


quote:

Chipper was ridiculously out. Quit bitching.



Mean't nothing. You're dumb






Back to top
BoulderDawg34
Georgia Fan
Boulder CO
Member since Sep 2012
254 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


Both horrible, but this is supposed to be the best umpires MLB has, and those replacement tards had no business being there. Infield fly rule, 60 ft. in the grass, should NEVER be called. So Braves call was worse to me. I'm a Braves fan too, so obviously a little prejudiced.





Back to top
SBC
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2005
3663 posts

re: Worse Call: GB/Seattle MNF or ATL/StL MLB Playoff?


He was camped? Did you watch the play?





Back to top



Back to top